Need help on deciding between Retrievers

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jason

Guest
Look guys, if you actually do the research to formulate your opinions I'd be more than happy to listen with an open mind. Until then, you're as ignorant as I am.
 

Fran27

Active Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2005
Messages
10,642
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
46
Location
New Jersey
Quote from the post at the top of the puppy forum :

Hobby Breeder : A breed fancier who usually has only one breed but may have two follows a breeding plan in efforts to preserve and protect the breed they are raising produces from none to five litters per year breeds only when a litter will enchance the breed and breeding program raises the puppies with pleanty of enviromental and human contact has a contract that protects the breeder, dog, and buyer runs a small clean kennel screens breeding stock to eliminate heredity defects from the breed works with a breed club or kennel club to promote and protect the breed and cares that each and every puppy is placed in the best home possible
I put in bold what that labradoodle.com site lacks, which makes it a dog factory as far as I am concerned.

If you can find any breeder that 1-does health testing on the parents, 2- doesn't breed them before they are 2 year old, 3- doesn't leave the mom and puppies in cages, 4- spends time with each puppy, 5- inquires about the buyer instead of just asking for a check, 6- doesn't charge the price of a pure bred puppy, 7- doesn't have over 5 litters a year, 8- doesn't have over 10 dogs for breeding, 9- doesn't breed the bitches more than once every 2 years

then maybe I will change my mind about labradoodle breeders only being in it for the money. Feel free to send me a link to convince me that I am wrong.


And I don't know about the others, but you saying we are as ignorant as you is definitely an insult... I think lots of people here have proven that they are far from being ignorant, you're just too bnarrow minded and blind to see it.

Why do I even bother posting anyway...
 
J

Jason

Guest
Fran27 said:
Quote from the post at the top of the puppy forum :



I put in bold what that labradoodle.com site lacks, which makes it a dog factory as far as I am concerned.

If you can find any breeder that 1-does health testing on the parents, 2- doesn't breed them before they are 2 year old, 3- doesn't leave the mom and puppies in cages, 4- spends time with each puppy, 5- inquires about the buyer instead of just asking for a check, 6- doesn't charge the price of a pure bred puppy, 7- doesn't have over 5 litters a year, 8- doesn't have over 10 dogs for breeding, 9- doesn't breed the bitches more than once every 2 years

then maybe I will change my mind about labradoodle breeders only being in it for the money. Feel free to send me a link to convince me that I am wrong.


And I don't know about the others, but you saying we are as ignorant as you is definitely an insult... I think lots of people here have proven that they are far from being ignorant, you're just too bnarrow minded and blind to see it.

Why do I even bother posting anyway...
You can't possibly learn all those things just by browsing a website. I also don't expect you to call Australia, so you can think what you want and I'll continue to keep an open mind until I can ask those questions directly to them.
 
S

stirder

Guest
the problem is that you are totally unwilling to concede that anyone might know more than you. labradoodles are nothing new, ttheyve been around for atleast a few years. you still havnt answered the most significant question jason. what do you like about the labradoodle that you cant find in ANY other breed???
 
S

stirder

Guest
Im pretty sure someone posted the question already, but Im not going to go back and read 17 pages of all this. maybe he missed the question, replies came in pretty fast a few times. I'll post it again just incase he missed it that time too....what do you like about the labradoodle that you cant find in ANY other breed???
forget for the moment wether they should be bred, before arguing any further wether they are responsible breeders or not, answer that question for us. maybe we'd be a little more willing to get off your case and just tell you what questions to ask, and what answers to find acceptable, if we understood why you think so highly of this mutt????
 
J

Jason

Guest
stirder said:
the problem is that you are totally unwilling to concede that anyone might know more than you. labradoodles are nothing new, ttheyve been around for atleast a few years. you still havnt answered the most significant question jason. what do you like about the labradoodle that you cant find in ANY other breed???
My wife wants a Golden and I don't want a dog that sheds on that level. Simple. I should also add that my neighbor bought a LD from Tegan and it's a wonderful dog.
 
Joined
Nov 24, 2004
Messages
600
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
33
Location
Indiana
Jason said:
Look guys, if you actually do the research to formulate your opinions I'd be more than happy to listen with an open mind.
I have done my research. That is what caused me to formulate my opinions. I don't state my opinion on something unless I know what I am talking about. If I don't know, then I go and find out, from different resources.

I'm now looking at this website: www.rutlandmanor.com
When I was out walking my dogs (again), I thought of something else that doesn't seem quite right about these people. They said something about you being put on a waiting list for a certain color, sex, coat type, etc. and then as soon as they have one, they will let you know. That just doesn't seem quite right.
 
Joined
Nov 24, 2004
Messages
600
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
33
Location
Indiana
Jason said:
My wife wants a Golden and I don't want a dog that sheds on that level. Simple.
Maybe you have missed this...there are a LOT of posts. lol But because the "doodle" breeds don't have fixed genes, some shed a LOT just like a Golden would, and some shed normally. The reason these breeds were discontinued in the Companion dog thing was because they did shed.
And one of these mutts sound much more higher matience than a Golden. More like, Poodle matience.
 
J

Jason

Guest
Rose's Gal said:
I have done my research. That is what caused me to formulate my opinions. I don't state my opinion on something unless I know what I am talking about. If I don't know, then I go and find out, from different resources.
I don't think you've ever really researched Labradoodle breeders. You don't need to unless you are going to make claims you can't back up. Understand something here, I haven't done the research either. I'm not saying anything definitively pro or con about the breeders themselves. All I keep saying is that making blanket statements and assumptions about people are wrong. Believing what you believe about breeder vs. rescue is fine, that's a subjective thing. Saying 99.9% of LD breeders are irresponsible is objective and incorrect.
 
S

stirder

Guest
your right rose, you should never pick a dog based on those criteria. health and temperment should be #1, everything else a distant 2nd 3rd etc. and according to MY "research" labradoodles shed just as much as goldens. but few labradoodles look like a golden. considering that fact, why not go with a golden, lab, chesapeake bay retriever, wire haired pointing griffon, chinook, flat coated retriever, brittany spaniel, and a lot of others??? you are looking at the labradoodle because you want a golden, but you want something that sheds less. most labradoodles shed just as much as goldens, some shed more. I just dont understand.
 
S

stirder

Guest
I said in a previous post, a thousand pages ago, that I HAVE contacted quite a few labradoodle breeders, read about them online, and read about them in a veterinary journal, where the OFA quoted that they have only certified 10 labradoodles. all 10 were a while ago, part of the original breeding experiments/programs, and ALL 10 have been spayed or neutered because the experiment failed.
since many labradoodles shed as much or more than a golden, WHY NOT LOOK AT REAL BREEDS!!!!!!!
 
Joined
Nov 24, 2004
Messages
600
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
33
Location
Indiana
I don't understand either Stirder. He wants a Golden, so he wants a Lab/Poodle mix, that looks like a Huge Bichon Frise or a Bouvier Des Flandres? That befuses (confused mixed with befuddled. lol) me.
I have done research about the "Doodle" breeders. That is why I have written who knows how long of pages about the subject! I've looked at countless breeders of these "doodles" and I have yet to find one that I'm happy with! I don't recall, out of all of my experience with dogs and different breeds, anyone ever telling me, "Hey, I just found a really good responsible Doodle breeder!" Never.
 
S

stirder

Guest
Jason said:
how is it false??? have you done ANY research into the so called breed??? who told you that wasnt true? oh, lemme guess, a labradoodle breeder.
try finding someone who has a labradoodle, and doesnt breed them, and ask them how much it sheds. to be accurate you'll have to find quite a few though.
 
Joined
Feb 5, 2005
Messages
6,125
Likes
0
Points
0
I know someone who owns a "labradoodle" and got her from a breeder. She bought her because the breeder said that if she didn't, the dog was going to go the shelter. They liked the idea of "no shedding" but wowie wow wow the dog sheds!
 
Joined
Feb 5, 2005
Messages
6,125
Likes
0
Points
0
Labs and goldens have a heavy shedding rate - I should get a picture up of how much I can get off of my lab. I can get a foot tall pile just from her hips and shoulders. Because a "labradoodle" has lab in it (and is half lab), there's a 50% it's going to shed like a lab.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

No members online now.
Top