Out of your batch I like: Peanut Butter Cup.
But MY favorite is the apple pie ice cream that Baskin Robbins makes, Mmm mmm good. I love it so much. Followed by strawberry with REAL strawberries in it. Yummy.
Store bought I'm pretty easy to please - I like anything chocolate. Right now I'm on a huggggeee mint chocolate chip kick, so that's what I vote. Before that it was bubblegum.
But if I go to Coldstone or something it's banana with Reese's Pieces mixed in. SO AMAZING. I also love Kawartha's Tiger Tail.