What is YOUR favorite Ice Cream?

[-bogart-]

I was the lucky recipent of an Ice Cream maker for my Birthday.
I have made Banana Ice Cream last night . Ths kids all loved it and I am pretty stoked on all I can do with it.

So my next batch I need some help deciding.

Chocolate
Pistachoe
Cake Batter Flavored
Satsuma ( small citrus fruit)
Peanut Butter Cup
Dr Pepper
Strawberry Cheesecake

Are all i am planning on making , but I cant decide which to try now.
HELP ME PLEASE , or complicate it more by adding a flavor I should try

 

[vanillasugar]

I enjoy a really well made vanilla. I like chocolate mint too

 

[ACooper]

Well, out of your list I'd pick pistachio.....(it's my second favorite).......MY favorite is butter pecan Sorry for adding complications! LOL

 

[-bogart-]

owwwww yeah I am looking for some Vanilla Beans around here , and waiting till I get my next week off to go to the grove and pick pecans , it should be time soon with all the wind.! soo woot 2 more to my list.

Chris LOVES this local bakery that make Pistachoe and I am trying to trump them , hopefully i can , there ice cream is like 6 dollars a pint and he doesn't get it often.

 

[Taqroy]

I looooooove peach flavored ice cream. Out of your flavors listed though I'd go with cake batter. Nom.

 

[JessLough]

I love chocolate mint/mint chip. Oh and chocolate chip cookie dough. And Peanut Butter Cup. Dr. Pepper sounds interesting.

ETA: My dad got an ice cream maker for Father's Day or Christmas or something. Do you have the bowl you have to stick in the freezer before making the ice cream? If you do, hint of advice, do NOT touch the middle of that bowl when it is frozen... my mom did once to take it out of the freezer, if she had not thought quickly enough, she would have gotten frostbite from it.

 

[-bogart-]

1 for pistachoe , 1 cake batter from my list ,
and 3 new flavors for the list! woot .

Mint Chocolate chip ( I can use the yorks from halloween as chunks!)
Butter pecan
Peach

The cake batter one calls for white cake , i may use yellow instead .......

It was so so easy to do and the ingrediants/reipies all range from 2 yr old can dump and poor , to wow thats alot to do for ice cream!

The banana one was a can evaporated milk , sugar , smooshed bananas.
seriously , i was floored when i read the pamplet that said i could substitute heavy cream for milk/canned milk. made this whole adventure so much cheaper and fun!

sorry to ramble , but I am super stoked on spending awesome family time making super yummy (and healthy) treats !

 

[-bogart-]

yeah jess . it is the bowl one. thanks for the tip , i only handle the bowl because it is to cold for the kids! i need me fingers!

I am making the dr pepper one up completly . i hope it comes out well.

 

[sparks19]

I don't have a favorite ice cream. I'm actually not a big fan of ice cream... GASP I know lol. I'll eat it if there isn't anything else sweet around but it's rare when I do eat it.

I do like peanut butter and chocolate ANYTHING so that would probably be my favorite ice cream too lol

 

[milos_mommy]

I love Cinnamon bun ice cream.

Hazelnut is also a good one to make with your ice cream maker.

I got an ice cream maker in June, and STILL haven't used it

 

[HayleyMarie]

Well my favorite is cookie dough with lots of cooking dough in it.

I can't stand vanilla. BLAH!

 

[MandyPug]

Amaretto Ice Cream
Chocolate Black Cherry Ice Cream
Tiger Ice Cream
Bubblegum Ice Cream
Cotton Candy Ice Cream

Lol that's all i've got for now and i love ALL those flavours.

 

[~Jessie~]

Peppermint Stick is my favorite flavor... which should be coming out in stores soon for the holidays!

 

[iwantmypup]

Pistachio is my absolute favorite ice cream ever!
I got the ice cream maker attachment for my kitchen aid mixer a while back and I still haven't used it, Ice cream making seems like such a long process, lol.

 

[MPP]

Chocolate Black Cherry? Really? That sounds absolutely to-die-for!

I vote for coffee ice cream with chocolate chunks and lots of roasted nuts. If I can't have chocolate black cherry. I'm flexible, though. Anything but vanilla.

 

[Laurelin]

My favorite is mint (peppermint is #1, but mint chocolate chip is 2nd). But that's not on the list... so I say chocolate.

 

[~Jessie~]

My vote goes towards chocolate for your next flavor

 

[-bogart-]

the next flavor will be chocolate with halloween candy mixed in!

I have been cruising the net and found so so smany things to make. it is unreal!
and i can make them healthy so i can eat even more frozen goodnessess!

 

[nikkiluvsu15]

My favorite Ice Creams are the "special" ones they have at Publix. They have the best flavors ever My favorites at the moment are "It's Your Birthday Cake" and "Lemon Sugar Cookie". Sooooo good.

 

[Renee750il]

Godiva Belgian Dark Chocolate.

If I were making homemade ice cream it would be dark, dark chocolate mocha.