Mixing Dog Foods

ToscasMom

Harumph™©®
Joined
Sep 15, 2006
Messages
6,211
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Mother Ship
#41
No answer yet from Eagle Pack. Maybe they just think the question is so stupid as to not require an answer. lol. I hold out hope I will hear from them though. If I don't get an answer I am just going to finish up the Eagle Pack and keep her on Natural Balance with a raw egg and leave it at that. I will never be satisfied with the answers that it can cause problems without some actual statistical proof though. Assumptions can actually travel around the world like that. It's not that I think nobody is telling the truth. It's just that the answers are touchy feely wherever I read about it. This can happen. That can happen. But nothing that shows me actuals. How many dogs have suffered ill effects from mixing foods? What foods were they on? How did we determine that their problems had to do with mixing foods, scientifically, subjectively, what? Things like that. Maybe it's out there but if it is I haven't found it yet. I just saw a site that said it's a great idea. I have no means of determining whether that's bull or not either. I am left with math and math tells me, "Whattttttt???".

But as with all things like this, I guess it is really best not to take the chance whether I ever see actuals or not. I had no idea till now that this was even an issue. My vet didn't think it was a problem but then we all know vets aren't all exactly nutrition experts. I just want to do what's best for my dog just like everybody else. Even if Eagle Pack says it's fine I can't be sure without real actuals, and I don't think they will say it's ok, because the link to the greatdane lady Herschel posted in this thread says it's not a good thing to do and she practically IS Eagle Pack. Her links to "why' are dead links, so I am right back where I started. With an opinion regarding balance that defies the math. Still she does offer links to other foods besides Eagle Pack that she recommends, so she can't be all THAT subjective. Then Team Canidae says no it's not ok but yes it is. So maybe I am just waiting to hear what I want to hear and that's not very scientific either. Still, the Ferret in me wants something more definitive past the belief or assumption. Im sure it must be out there or so many experts wouldn't be agreeing, right?
 

ToscasMom

Harumph™©®
Joined
Sep 15, 2006
Messages
6,211
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Mother Ship
#42
Oh, as I mentioned the greatdanelady's links to possible problems is dead so I looked up the terms.

One is Pano. Here is an interesting link on it that cites Overdosing of calcium, phosphorus and protein.
http://www.jersey.net/~mountaindog/berner1/lpano.htm

The other is HOD, which seems to have more to do with protein intake at a young age in large and medium breed dogs. Here's a link on that:
http://www.workingdogs.com/doc0018.htm

The third acronym is OCD, I am assuming this refers to Osteochondritis Dissecans rather than Obsessive Compulsive Disorder. The link cites diet as a warning against not letting your dog get overweight.Here's a link.

http://www.thepetcenter.com/xra/ocd.html


http://www.workingdogs.com/doc0018.htm
 

Herschel

New Member
Joined
May 16, 2006
Messages
3,303
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
East Central Illinois
#43
Toscas Mom,

Sounds like Natural Balance + egg will work great for you. If Eagle Pack decides to respond, please post the answer! (I believe their nutritionist is John. Mordy has his contact information)

Yeah--I'm not sure if I can say that I agree with the GreatDaneLady. None of us are dealing with giant breeds, and I can't see how mixing two high quality foods can lead to an overdose in anything...
 

rij73

New Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2006
Messages
642
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Brooklyn, NY
#44
Wow, I just noticed this thread... Good luck with the decision! I researched food as soon as I started *thinking* about getting a dog and settled on Natural Balance for a variety of reasons. BUT, Hudson is about 1 year old, so I didn't really have the puppy/protein issue to consider.

Sounds to me like the added egg or even a little added meat or fish would be just fine, though. Actually rotating a few different added protein sources could conceivably be the best thing for Tosca as she would be getting fresh food and a little variety. Hmm...
 
B

Bobsk8

Guest
#45
The Animal Nutritionist from Natural Balance who has a degree in this field, responded to my email. She said that there is no problem in mixing different kinds of kibble,keeping in mind that if food allergies are a concern, that you don't select a kibble that the dog is allergic to. That's pretty much what I had figured...
 
Joined
May 24, 2006
Messages
229
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Minnesota
#46
I asked my nutrition professor at school... Keep in mind, this was a in-the-hallway, can-I-ask-a-quick-question sort of thing, so it may not be a complete answer, BUT...

She said that, provided both foods are completed and balanced, and appropriate for your dog's life stage, and we are talking about a healthy dog, there should be no problems in mixing foods. She also said that there are enough dog foods out there that you shouldn't have a problem finding one that meets all of your needs. But, if it makes you as an owner feel more comfortable about what you are feeding, feel free to do it, as it won't have any negative impact on your dog.

Good luck!
 

ToscasMom

Harumph™©®
Joined
Sep 15, 2006
Messages
6,211
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Mother Ship
#48
I didn't want you folks to think I abandoned my responsibility here. I want you to know that I have NOT gotten a response from the Eagle Pack people at all so far.
 
B

Bobsk8

Guest
#50
But the people at Eagle Pack have such good communication...blah blah blah....Canidae doesn't respond to any emails...blah blah.

:)

Sorry, I'm just being a pest. Haha.
Natural Balance always responds with a day... ;) ;) Maybe they are more organized.....
 

ToscasMom

Harumph™©®
Joined
Sep 15, 2006
Messages
6,211
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Mother Ship
#51
Ok Troops, The Eagle Has landed. Scuse me if I removed my email address and the sender's address. I don't want to be responsible for spam to him either.

Subj: RE: Eagle Pack Questions/Comments
Date: 11/28/2006 12:15:09 PM Eastern Standard Time
From: [email protected][/email]
To: [email protected]
Sent from the Internet (Details)


Hello,

…and we are sorry for the delay in responding. You can mix the 2 foods and still get the benefits of the Eagle.



Thanks for being so loyal,



John



-----Original Message-----
From: Eagle Pack Pet Foods [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Monday, November 20, 2006 9:39 AM
To: Marsman
Subject: FW: Eagle Pack Questions/Comments







-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected]
Sent: Friday, November 17, 2006 3:18 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Eagle Pack Questions/Comments



Hi!

I'm in a bit of a quandry here. I am a rabid Eagle Pack fan. I have fed my cats Eagle for years and they all seem to live well above the average and do very well. I now have a Collie dog. I want her to eat Eagle Pack and I have tried all of your foods for her. She just doesn't have much gusto for it. This bothers me because I am an Eagle Pack fan, but at the same time I want my dog to enjoy eating. So I began mixing Eagle Pack with Natural Balance in a half/half mixture. This mixture works well for her appetite it seems. She loves it.

I have read conflicting information on whether or not this is a healthy thing to do, so I am asking your opinion on it. I do not want to force my dog to eat that which doesn't make her happy and at the same time I am in a struggle because I want her to get at least some Eagle Pack benefit.

Your advise would be greatly appreciated.
 
B

Bobsk8

Guest
#52
It seems that all the companies so far that were contacted responded with an " It's OK to mix" answer, which is what I thought all along......
 

Members online

Top