No, definitely not as good as real life in terms of "home". But I have DEFINITELY learned some things I needed to learn about dogs and about the way Tosca thinks. I came here TOTALLY dog ignorant. There are several VERY knowledgable people here whose words I trust. Also, I work from my computer and that can be tedious, so Chaz is a great place for me to click on for breaks while learning something from some folks at the same time. Yes, it is true it is clicky but that doesn't matter to me. I've never been good at joining clubs, I'm kind of allergic to that kind of thing anyways, so I don't let it bother me much. Most sites are clicky, no less so than here, even though sites all try to hide it. It's palpable, really, but since it's not real life in terms of actually "knowing" everyone, it shouldn't really matter in terms of learning valuable things about dogs. ....And if learning and getting some valuable advice is your goal, Chaz is a really good place to go.