It seems like they are going thru an awful lot of trouble to continuously post this stuff just to rile us up and confuse us. Unless one was an older post and now he got another dog, etc... I mean, maybe he didn't explain things fully and one dog is, say, his moms or something. I mean, I consider my Max to be my dog but he is actually my moms, she also has 3 cats. At my house I have a ton of cats but no dogs. So if someone wanted to compare my posts, you might find conflicting information.
So I give people the benefit of the doubt...BUT...the fact that he is unclear and NEVER comes back to reply and answer our questions makes me think it is very suspecious behavior. All he would have to do is come back and say, "wait guys let me clear this up..." etc, then we would know. But he just leaves his threads hanging and never replies back enough for us to know if he is serious or not.
So OP if you are reading this and want to make us understand what is going on and get more help with your questions, even though they have been answered loud and clear numerous times all over the internet dog forums, explain yourself and answer our questions so we can help you, alright?