Wysong vs. California Natural

[Pomp]

My brother's cat food food was recalled and now he needs to pick a new food. Fortunately, his cat has shown no symptoms but we are getting her checked out anyway.

Regardless, he needs to make a switch. Also, his cat is allergic to chicken and beef, thus he needs a food without either of them. I could only find two. Could someone give their opinion on which is better:

Wysong:

http://www.petfooddirect.com/store/...age=&mscssid=EUU9TKMT14VS8MKB47F7EER7LSWR9538

California Natural Herring and Sweet Potato:

http://www.petfooddirect.com/store/...age=&mscssid=EUU9TKMT14VS8MKB47F7EER7LSWR9538

Thank you.

 

[vanillasugar]

I like California Natural better. Wysong makes incredible suppliments, but their food leaves a lot to be desired IMO.

Plus, the way Wysong has designed their food, even if it's "complete" they want you to rotate with other brands, and with fresh foods, as their philosophy is that any one food is not good enough (inlcuding their own). Besides that, you've picked Anergen, which is a canine/feline diet, and I wouldn't feel 100% comfortable feeding this exclusively.

 

[Buddy'sParents]

To be honest, I wouldn't go with either. But, if I had to chose.. it would be california natural.

 

[ToscasMom]

I am definitely not a Wysong fan but cannot comment on Cal Natural. May I suggest you try Felidae?