White Shepherd - History, Myths and Misconceptions

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#1
I thought I would do a biref post on my own breed – partially because I really do like blathering on about them, but also because there are a lot of misconceptions about White Shepherds, White German Shepherds and White Swiss Shepherd Dogs. LOL – and I am also sort of practicing for writing a pamphlet for puppy buyers in the future – so I figured I get my ideas down and then spend a couple of weeks researching.

First though I will start with the history of the white coat in the GSD. The Father of the German Shepherd – CPT Max v. Stephanitz – chose a male named Horand v. Grafrath to be the ‘first’ German Shepherd. Horand had all the qualities he was looking for in a dog – and as a result of being that first sire he was heavily bred and bred and bred.
What many don’t know is that Horand had a white grandfather – a dog named Greif, and he was a carrier for the White Allele. Through the extensive breeding on Horand, the white coat became a fixture in the breed (it was not a mutation). During the early years of the breed many colors and coat types exhisted that we do not see today – brindle, wire coats, piebalds, tiger strips on tan points, etc…and while the CPT may have prefered one color over another, he did not advocate for the removal of a dog based on their color. His words regarding the white coat were that it was dull, lackluster, and unexciting (essentially) and that he didn’t much care for it (he prefered the Sable). He also didn’t much like the solid black either. (side note : I have the 1924 edition of the GSD in Word and Picture – which is where I draw my information from on this topic).

Greif :


Horand :

In the early to mid-30’s the white coat became a disqualification under the SV. No one really knows for sure who did it or why – but the most widely accepted theory was that Hitler didn’t much care for the white coats and thus disqualified them. We do know that it was around this time that the common misconception that the white was linked to hereditary diseases such as deafness and blindness started being circulated. After this time the whites and their carriers were so efficiently culled from the population that today the allele is all but nonexistent in the European populations.

However – the situation was greatly different in America. One of the founding members of the SDCA - Ann Tracy – brought German Shepherds from Europe who were either white or carrying for the white allele. There are several historical pictures that can be found of her and her white dogs – one such example is a full page dedicated to a picture of her and a helper training a white – Stonihurst Bero – in protection (J.Hered; 1924; The Origin of the Shepherd Dog).
Throughout the years the whites flourished in the United States. In addition to Ann Tracy’s dogs, Geraldine Rockefeller Dodge was also a proponent of the whites. White GSDs appeared in comics, on TV and in movies.



 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#2
In 1968 however, things changed when the GSDCA made the decision to disqualify the white coat from the show ring. However, unlike Europe, the dogs were still registerable in the AKC – and many fanciers made the decision to continue breeding whites in order to save the allele.

The WGSDCII (White German Shepherd Dog Club International Inc) was formed to give fanciers a club to show in and a support network of breeders whom knew the others were reliable and respectable. Their mission was not only to provide an outlet for the coat in conf. venues, but was also to try and lobby to have the disqualification removed.

Overtime that club broke into three other clubs – the WGSDCII remained, but from it came the WGSDCA (White German Shepherd Dog Club of America) and the AWSA (American White Shepherd Association). I am not 100% certain of the reason for the split between the WGSDCII and WGSDCA – but I do know they share the same goal of having the whites remain a part of the German Shepherd and having the DQ removed. Many of the WGSD folks (there are WGSD and WS/WSSD folks mainly) have German Shepherds in their lines – mainly because that’s what they want. For the most part they tend towards the Amline type of breeding – albeit the all breed structure.

AWSA is the ‘seperatist’ club. It was formed in 1994 by WS owners and breeders who were unhappy with the state of affairs and whom no longer felt there was any great chance of the disqualification being removed from the GSD standard….it was founded on a strict code of ethics and remains that way today. AWSA holds a standard separate from the GSD, and the breeders will breed for that – AWSA also offers shows and frequently has herding, therapy, and ATTS events at their shows and nationals. Most of these people are WS people : ie – they want a separate breed. However – the majority of the dogs are still AKC GSDs – and because of this there are some members who will bring colored lines into their breedings – however, the majority of the breeders follow white to white. Recently they have decided to accept FCI pedigrees (YAY!) which is in a small way helping to separate the WS from the AKC and the GSD.

In 1998 AWSA lobied for the UKC to accept the white shepherd as a breed separate from the GSD and provided the 1000 dogs necissary to hve the seperation occur. Because AWSA wanted to remain active on the AKC front – the United White Shepherd Club was formed – UWSC. Another important part of our breed is the White Shepherd Genetics project – which is a database that records and studies the health of the Whites. This project has been very successful at raising health awarness and producing genetic pedigrees that help to either study or eliminate the health issues that do occur in our breed.

And that leads onto another part of the history of the White Shepherd : Europe. While the allele for white was diminished greatly in Europe, a very few small breeders still continued to breed whites. In the 60’s, a woman named Agathe Burch moved from America to Switzerland – brining her white male, Lobo with her. She imported other white dogs from the US, though she eventually sold the dogs to a Swiss man – Kurt Kron. A small group of fanciers in Switzerland set up their own breed and breed standard using these lines and very severe health testing. They pulled additional lines from some of the few European whites, and some from the English – but the majority of the stock can be traced back to American Whites. Other clubs started popping up around Europe – Austria, Germany and Holland. Eventually the SKG recognized the breed as White Shepherds. Around the turn of the century the White Shepherd fanciers lobied the FCI to gain recognition as a separate breed – and that was granted in 2002. Today the White Shepherd is known by many names across Europe…in many different languages, but the most common is Berger Blanc Suisse – or White Swiss Shepherd Dog. These dogs are granted full papers by the kennel clubs of the various nations – with a big ole FCI approved stamp in the corner 

Lobo :


Agathe Burch :


Champion von Kron :
 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#3
So where does that leave the breed today? Convoluted – as I suppose you already guessed. AWSA is at a roadblock right now because they need the permission of the GSDCA to remove the white coat from the standard before the AKC accepts them as a separate breed – but that would mean the loss of something like 5000 registered dogs per year for that breed. The Europeans are separate, the American dogs are not with the exception of those dogs imported from Europe. There is a decent amount of tension between the WGSD and WS folks – some members wont have anything to do with each other; some of the WGSD folk are so against seperation that they would rather eradicate their line than separate the breeds. The Europeans will not accept AKC registered GSDs, but will accept AWSA registered WSs. AKC wont register the WSSDs from Europe as anything.

As I said – convolution…but that is our history until we can get things solved.

But here are some of the misconceptions I have heard.

“If the white shepherd and GSD are separate breeds – isnt it mixing to breed the two together?”-Depends on who you are talking to…it’s not something I would do. If you want to be factual though most of the Whites in the US are GSDs and thus it is just breeding two GSDs together. Now…for those of us that have imports – it would be a mix – Ruby is all WSSD with no GSD papers – and I would never consider taking her to a GSD!

“Is the White Albino? Doesn’t that cause health issues?”-No – the white coat is caused by the most recessive of the three alleles at the extension locus…and rather than being white is really more of a cream…this is the same allele that causes whites in (probably) yorkies, sammies, eskies; and it is the same allele that causes yellow in labs. Additionally the allele doesn’t affect the skin – it is something called a ‘masking’ gene – meaning it only changes the fur and nothing else. More information can be found here :

http://homepage.usask.ca/~schmutz/white.html

“I’ve heard that whites can’t herd because they are white”-This is probably one of my favorites – mainly because I have worked with sheep and have also taken my dogs herding and watched other whites herding at AWSA Nationals. For one – rare is the sheep that is as white/cream as my dog – it’s not hard to pick them out of the flock. Another nifty one is that sheep don’t respect the white coat – again – I can tell you from personal experience that the sheep don’t much care for either of my dogs…whose prey drive kicks into overdrive around sheep (can you say crook!) And in general – yes – most whites have the integral drives needed to herd still.

This is a sort of interesting story regarding that : http://www.regalwise.com/pixpages/herding.html


“I’ve heard whites can’t work”

-this is another one I take great pleasure in…and one I have a personal interest in disproving. For one thing – there are a great deal of working whites in Europe…and if anyone is interested I can pull up a short list I compiled of a few of the dogs I found. I will say that in the US there has been a general movement away from protection sport and towards other sports like agility, flyball and herding because many hope to avoid the dangerous dog reputation that the GSD has (that I’ve been subjected too :( ) – which has lead to a certain water down of drives – but it by no means has affected the entire population…and there are several breeders in the US maintaining working drives and a good solid temperment also suited to working. No for other things – there are whites active in Narc, SAR, and Service – and there are also whites who have gone onto Canine (though I see more whites in K9 in Europe than here). There are two FEMA whites in the Canine Hero’s of 9/11 book (there might actually be more) and my own Leo is from a line that has produced K9s and SAR dogs in the past.





 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#4
And I am going to show some males typical of Europe and some typical of America so you can get an idea of what they look like as well.

European :








As far as the differencs between European and American Dogs, from the European dogs you are going to see a little bit less angulation – both in the pasterns and in the rear, slightly better secondary sex characteristics, a shallower chest, a steeper croup albiet with good tail sets, better shoulders, and a tendency towards coats. You do tend to see better pigment over all in Europe as well.
 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#5
American :








The American dogs tend to have a great deal more chest, are frquently over the size limit (though not by much), lean towards stock coats, have more angulation in the rear and generally have a better croup (though sometimes there is plug-in tail). I like them both…Ruby is very atypically European, and Leo is very American – though he is going to be a smaller male once he finishes growing.
 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#6
And of coarse I can’t leave without adding pictures of my two!! (Yeah…I know….I should be more modest…but I have two awsome pups o_O) They’ve both got a lot of maturing to do though o_O

Ruby :

@ 10 months


@14 months

Leo :

@ 7 months


@ 9 months

That’s all I can think of for right now…if you have any questions I would be very happy to answer them – lol – mainly because you’d probably be brining up a point I failed to remember to mention (something that would be useful towards the things I am working on.) Hope this was informative!!

~Cate
 

JennSLK

F150 and a .30-06
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
6,956
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
38
Location
Alberta
#9
Cool. Thanks. I have allways compared them to Albino dobes. Thanks fo more info
 
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
639
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
86,Fr
#10
Great posts,thanks,love the European dogs better cos they have less angulation and love the rough coat but you know that!!.
As for Ruby,she is the one who made me take a double Look at the breed!!.
 

PWCorgi

Priscilla Winifred Corgi
Joined
Apr 12, 2006
Messages
14,854
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
34
Location
Twin Citay!
#12
Thanks for posting this, I learned a lot as well!

I never knew about all the different organizations, that was interesting to learn.
 

Dekka

Just try me..
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
19,779
Likes
3
Points
38
Age
48
Location
Ontario
#16
Thanks Its great to learn the 'real' scoop on breeds. As an owner of LHW I am constantly bombarded with misinformation.
 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#17
Thank you for posting! By the way, I love Ruby's topline. She looks very utilitarian. :)
Thanks! She's very athletic - which is one of the things I like so much about her - and her back is as solid as a rock :) She's an airborne striker too - which is so awsome to watch :p I'm going to try her in Agility at some point - she's just very, very athletic and should do pretty well in just about anything she tries.

Thanks everyone - one of the things that I have learned is that there are alot of misconceptions about my breed, and sometimes it helps to just post up information about them in hopes that it will clear some stuff up :)

~Cate
 

corgi_love

Active Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2008
Messages
1,254
Likes
0
Points
36
#18
When I was very young we had a White Shepherd. Her name was Porsche(my Dad loves Porsches..), she was a great dog!

Yours are beautiful. Great information, too! My boyfriend loves White Shepherds :D
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
2,365
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
High Ridge, MO
#19
One of the things that I find fascinating is that in the UKC, you will see white dogs being shown as German Shepherds, and then there will be the White Shepherds themselves as their own breed. And evidently you're not allowed to cross the two, but you can single-register a white GSD as a WS. I got a little lost when a handler was explaining it to me, and have forgotten half of what she said, but it must've made some kind of sense at the time.
 

Falconara

Gene Junkie
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
262
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
MD/DC/VA
#20
If you have an AKC GSD registration you can single register that dog with the UKC as a WS or WGSD - but you arent supposed to cross UKC GSDs and UKC WSs. Not all of the members of AWSA have their dogs dual registered with the UKC - so if a UKC owner wants to cross out to one of those dogs they have to single register ea. puppy I believe.

I am grateful to a certain extent about this because Leo came from a WGSDCII breeder (she was breeding for the drives I was looking for). None of her dogs where UKC registered though - and as a result I was able to register him as a WS in the UKC (I did talk to her about this first as well).

Again - it's all very convoluted o_O

~Cate
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top