Copycat, that's what I did last night!
For an ass-kicking, I like the Sailor Jerry's Spiced Navy Rum. It's like...92%. Way, way better than Cap'n Morgan.
One of my faves is Ron Matusalem. I'd love to pick up a bottle of the anejo at some point, but so far all I've been able to find is the platino.
Mount Gay isn't bad either.