"pit bull attack" story

short1216

New Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
Messages
39
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ohio
#1
This story aired on my channel 3 news last night....




CLEVELAND -- A Cleveland mail carrier who was attacked by a pit bull October 11 says he thought the dog might kill him.
Jack Smith said he remembers that afternoon on E. 77th St. near St Clair vividly.

"As it progressed, I knew that I was in a fight for my life with this pit bull," Smith said.

Smith, a mail carrier for eight years, sat heavily bandaged in his Huron Hospital room Monday. He remembered how Colby, the dog, broke free from his chain and began a relentless attack.

"For the next seven to eight minutes after that it was just me against the dog face to face," Smith said. "(It) bit into my ... clamped on to my left arm and it was there two to three minutes and at that time, it broke my left arm."

There's still blood on the neighbor's porch where Smith said the dog was literally hanging off him, grabbing onto his chest with his mouth.

"I had to stand on my feet and keep it in front of me if I was going to make it out of there," Smith said.

A neighbor finally pulled the dog off of Smith. A woman in the house where the dog was tied up offered her regrets, though she declined to identify herself.

"I'm sorry, I apologize, I wish it had never happened, and God be with him."

But Jack Smith says the owners have to be held responsible and wonders why the city doesn't clamp down. Cleveland City Councilman Jay Westbrook offered one answer.

"We need to have the laws that we have fully enforced," Westbrook said. "We've had a difficulty being able to do that because of staffing levels."

For now, Smith faces months of rehabilitation. But he keeps his sense of humor.

"I'm just interested in getting my golf swing back and we'll see what happens as far as my postal career as it goes," he said.



:mad: This story irritated me enough to e-mail the reporters who covered the story..


I’m writing this in response to the story that you aired this evening, 10/16/06. I found the “pit bull” attack story very upsetting. First of all, my prayers are with the man who was attacked, however, I believe that your story contained an error. A “pit bull” is not a breed of dog, it is a term under which 25 plus dogs can be either classified under or confused for. The main three dogs being, the American Pit Bull Terrier (APBT), the American Staffordshire Terrier (AMSTAFF), and the Staffordshire Bull Terrier (STAFFY). There are many stories of “pit bull attacks”, but in most cases these dogs are not even bully breeds, but are mixed breed dogs. If one cannot guarantee the breed of a dog, a breed should not be mentioned. Responsible owners of bully breeds are having a hard enough time dealing with the ridiculous BSL laws without having to worry about more negative press due to people’s ignorance. I wish you would cover a story about the loyalty, bravery, and downright love that American Pit Bull Terriers posses. How about doing a story on Popsicle, the U.S.A.’s best drug sniffing customs agent or Sgt. Stubby, the U.S.A.’s first official war dog? I am well aware of the fact that a story like that may not be as exciting or get the feedback as a story which portrays these wonderful dogs as evil, but I think that you, being such a large media outlet have a certain responsibility to fulfill. Spread awareness, not ignorance. If they were human, this would be called racism.

Sincerely,
Jen Elardo
 
Joined
Oct 2, 2006
Messages
253
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
KS USA
#3
Sad :( I've met so many good APBT's with good owners, but I do often see ones that look vicious while walking the neighborhood with my own dogs. There's a world of difference if you just look around at the conditions the animals are kept in... the ones who are snapping, growling, snarling and biting are usually living in a small yard with several other big, just as bad-tempered dogs inside a fence and never seem to go anywhere else, or they are chained outside with very little interaction. The ones who are affectionate, companionable, and well-trained are nearly always at their owners' sides and get treated with lots of attention, love and respect. I agree with your e-mail, though I would have added that the reason the mail carrier was attacked is more likely due to the dog being chained outside (I would guess the dog probably spends most of its life on that chain) and having little interaction with people. Just look at the quotes from the woman in the house...it doesn't even say if this is her dog, just that she lives there! So obviously no one is taking care of this animal, or the person doesn't want to admit to owning a dog like this now that someone's been hurt and there's a potential for a lawsuit, etc. The breed itself is only noteworthy in the article because there has been so much bad publicity toward this type of dog, but it is the enviornment the dog lives in which causes behavior like this.
 

iheartsammy

ME+DOGS=CRAZY
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
2,220
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
32
Location
Northern California
#4
The only pit I've ever seen that looked 'mean' were the ones on chains or kept in the backyard. All the pits I've ever met that were being walked were all very nice dogs.
 

short1216

New Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
Messages
39
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ohio
#6
As far as "mean looking pits" go, thats kind of an unfair generalization....a lot of people think that APBTs are just " mean looking" . Just because its a large muscular breed with a big head doesnt make it mean. Thats really judging the book by it's cover. Besides, any breed can bite or look mean. In a test done by the American Temperment Testing Society, APBTs were in the 82 percentile meaning that 80% plus passed the temperment test, beating out some common family dogs such as Retrievers and Bichon Frise which tested at 77%. I am not trying to decriminate against any breed, I completely adore all dogs. I just think bully breeds are quite the underdog...no pun intended.
 
S

savethebulliedbreeds

Guest
#7
Good for you. Thank you so much for writing to them. Please keep us posted as to what happens.
 
S

savethebulliedbreeds

Guest
#8
Ahhhh, short don't get into American Temperment Tests lol. I have used that same thing before and I get negative feedback. Just a warning lol. :D
 

short1216

New Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
Messages
39
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ohio
#9
Lol...thanks for the warning! I just find the results interesting even if they arent 100% accurate
 
Joined
Oct 2, 2006
Messages
253
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
KS USA
#10
As far as "mean looking pits" go, thats kind of an unfair generalization....a lot of people think that APBTs are just " mean looking" . Just because its a large muscular breed with a big head doesnt make it mean. Thats really judging the book by it's cover. Besides, any breed can bite or look mean. In a test done by the American Temperment Testing Society, APBTs were in the 82 percentile meaning that 80% plus passed the temperment test, beating out some common family dogs such as Retrievers and Bichon Frise which tested at 77%. I am not trying to decriminate against any breed, I completely adore all dogs. I just think bully breeds are quite the underdog...no pun intended.
oh I agree totally, what I meant by mentioning that I have seen vicious-looking pits is what I said in the few sentences after that.... that the ones who look and act mean are kept in bad conditions with little human interaction. And by mean-looking, I don't mean the breed itself looks mean...I am talking about dogs that snap, growl, snarl and try to bite when someone passes by. I think the APBT is a beautiful breed. It is the bad owners who turn them into dangerous animals by abusing and neglecting them.
 
S

savethebulliedbreeds

Guest
#11
I find them extremely interesting also. Its kind of interesting to see some of those cute lap dogs down lower in %. It makes people think, i think. I own an Amstaff, 4 Pomeranians & 2 Chihuahuas and knowing my dogs extremely well, IF one of my dogs ever bit anyone, I can guarantee you 100% that it would be one of the little ones.

As a matter of fact I have been having a discussion with my brother in law lately because he asked us to look after his golden retriever, but told us not to let him near our amstaff. Well us knowing our amstaff would never hurt him, we introduced the two dogs. The amstaff (a breed having a reputation of being dog aggressive) wanted to play and the golden retriever (a breed having a reputation of being a well rounded dog) tried to attack him.

Before I get bashed for the above story, I would just like to say that this is one situation and not all breeds should be based on that. Each and every dog has its own personality. So I am definately not saying that all golden retrievers are like that or all amstaffs are not dog aggressive. This is just an example of differences in dogs and how some are far off from the way they are said to be.
 

short1216

New Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
Messages
39
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ohio
#14
People tell me that Sal looks mean all the time....you can't find a more friendly animal (not just a dog)
I think both of your dogs are beautiful...and Sal looks intelligent, not mean!
People say that Roush is cute now but I think its because hes still looks like a puppy. We'll see what happens as he grows.
 

iheartsammy

ME+DOGS=CRAZY
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
2,220
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
32
Location
Northern California
#15
As far as "mean looking pits" go, thats kind of an unfair generalization....a lot of people think that APBTs are just " mean looking" . Just because its a large muscular breed with a big head doesnt make it mean. Thats really judging the book by it's cover. Besides, any breed can bite or look mean. In a test done by the American Temperment Testing Society, APBTs were in the 82 percentile meaning that 80% plus passed the temperment test, beating out some common family dogs such as Retrievers and Bichon Frise which tested at 77%. I am not trying to decriminate against any breed, I completely adore all dogs. I just think bully breeds are quite the underdog...no pun intended.
oh I get you 100%! I just said 'mean' because I'm not the best with words and I thought you'd get what I ment.
 

elegy

overdogged
Joined
Apr 22, 2006
Messages
7,720
Likes
1
Points
0
#16
sorry... not seeing anything wrong with the story??

that dog needs to be put down. the owner needs to be fined heavily. chaining needs to be friggen outlawed because it produces so freaking many bites.

sigh.
 
Joined
Jul 28, 2005
Messages
457
Likes
0
Points
0
#18
chaining needs to be friggen outlawed because it produces so freaking many bites.

sigh.
I agree 100% with your statement. I think ANY breed left on the end of a chain would become frustrated and develop aggression issues. Who could blame them? :mad:
 

DanL

Active Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
3,933
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
61
#20
sorry... not seeing anything wrong with the story??
I think what short1216 didn't like is they said the dog was a pit bull. Again, how do we know it wasn't a pit bull? What is a pit bull? Like was already said, 20 something different breeds are considered pitbulls, and any combination of mixed breeds. So if that is the classification, call a spade a spade and let the reporter say it was a pit bull. Where did they get their info from? The owner of the dog? Do you think she's going to say he's 25% amstaff, 25% apbt, and 50% staffie? No, she's going to say "he's a pit bull"
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top