Punishment when it is harsh has a lot of bad side effects even with adult dogs. A tiny puppy cannot understand what you mean and usually learns only to fear and distrust you. Explicit trust in the relationship is the most important training tool you can have. Punishment does not show the dog what you want him TO do. It's much more effective to show the dog what it is you do want than what you don't.
Yes, she could have a bladder infection or simply a full bladder. In fact, a pup that young probably doesn't feel it at all until the very last second when she has to go. Do you see why punishment would be very detrimental now? At her age, the ability to control is just barely, if at all present. As she gets a little older, the concept to go outside will take time to learn. Sterness is not going to teach her. Showing her and making it better for her to go outside than inside will teach her. Preventing accidents by your proper supervision will help teach her. If she has an accident, it is not her fault. Its the owners'.....always.
Harsh punishment often backfires as it is sometimes associated with a behavior that you aren't targetting. This can cause real damage.
There are very effective ways to train without using aversives.
Yes, she could have a bladder infection or simply a full bladder. In fact, a pup that young probably doesn't feel it at all until the very last second when she has to go. Do you see why punishment would be very detrimental now? At her age, the ability to control is just barely, if at all present. As she gets a little older, the concept to go outside will take time to learn. Sterness is not going to teach her. Showing her and making it better for her to go outside than inside will teach her. Preventing accidents by your proper supervision will help teach her. If she has an accident, it is not her fault. Its the owners'.....always.
Harsh punishment often backfires as it is sometimes associated with a behavior that you aren't targetting. This can cause real damage.
There are very effective ways to train without using aversives.