Los Angeles Mandatory spay/neuter. Epic fail.

Romy

Taxiderpy
Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Messages
10,233
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Olympia, WA
#1
Cross posted from another list.

TX-RPOA E-News
>From RPOA Texas Outreach and
Responsible Pet Owners Alliance
"Animal welfare, not animal 'rights'
and, yes, there is a difference."
Permission granted to crosspost.

August 2, 2009
More information on the failure of Mandatory Pet Spay/Neuter with Intact
Animal Permits in Los Angeles, CA! Fax and/or email this information with
"Oppose Pet Spay/Neuter with Intact Animal Permits Ordinance" in the subject
line to all Fort Worth city officials below who will be voting on this
August 11th.

Record numbers of animals crowd shelters - The Daily Breeze
Record numbers of animals crowding shelters
By Dana Bartholomew Staff Writer
Posted: 07/28/2009 07:59:11 PM PDT

Los Angeles animal shelters are seeing a record number of furry friends -
and euthanasias - as a result of the down economy.

The shelters are so overcrowded that the Department of Animal Services is
offering two-for-one cat adoptions to make room for a feline influx.

The influx also can be attributed to spay and neuter ordinances being more
difficult to enforce for cats, many of whom are free-roaming, said Capt.
Daniel Pantoja, who oversees the Harbor Animal Care Center
in San Pedro.

"I'm at capacity and every other shelter is as well," Pantoja said. "We have
cats in cages in the hallways, in the lobby, in rooms that
are supposed to be for quarantined animals. We're using every space we can."

Rescue

Area animal shelters have been experiencing a feline population explosion.
The Harbor shelter was built with 24 cat kennels and they
currently are housing 104 cats and kittens. A cat rests in a kennel in the
lobby at the Harbor shelter. Cats are being kept all throughout
the shelter.

"We need some recuperation," said Kathy Davis, interim general manager of
the department. "We're certainly hoping at some point that the economy will
recover and, as a byproduct, people will quit turning
their animals in."

The surge in abandoned pets has continued unabated since May 2008, when
soaring job losses and home foreclosures began fueling an
increase in surrendered dogs and cats at city shelters.

In the fiscal year ending June 30, the number of dogs and cats turned in to
the city's six animal shelters soared 14 percent to 55,742 - the
highest in five years, according to city data.

But while pet adoptions increased 24 percent, so have the number of animals
killed, with cats bearing the brunt of euthanasias.

"Due to the economy, people are opening their doors and letting the animals
go because they have nowhere to take them," said Missy
Woodward of Reseda, on the board of Stray Cat Alliance.

"There's a desperate need for people to take in pets and spay and neuter
their own."

Pantoja said the new San Pedro shelter - which opened in June 2008 - was
built with only 24 cat cages.
"Twenty-four cages is not enough," he said.

The shelter at 957 N. Gaffey St. currently is holding 104 cats and 105 dogs
(with 74 dog kennels), he said, adding that animals are being euthanized for
reasons of "time and space."

"They're not sick or aggressive, but we've got to make room for new ones,"
he said.

Despite a spay-neuter law implemented last fall, the department destroyed
nearly 13,000 cats, a 30 percent increase, while unweaned
kitten kills rose 41 percent in 12 months.

Pantoja said the numbers of animals coming into the Harbor Area shelter have
grown over the past few years.

"Every summer, as soon as the heat waves start, the multiplying of cats
continues," Pantoja said. "People ignore the fact that spaying
and neutering cats is important."

The increase has incited animal welfare activists, who say the shelters are
"red-listing" - designating animals in immediate danger
of euthanasia - up to 40 cats a day.

Adding to the pressure is a decision made Tuesday by Gov. Arnold
Schwarzenegger to halve the mandated adoption time from six days to three,
and decrease funds to shelters as part of the 2010 state budget.

"I think it's a sad time for the animals in California," said Judie Mancuso,
founder of Social Compassion in Legislation, an animal
welfare advocacy group. "It creates a heavy burden to shelters across the
state."

Davis said that the minimum holding period for adoptable pets in Los Angeles
shelters will not change, despite the governor's action, with the average
adoption period of nine to 12 days.
"Our mission is, we're holding animals as long as we have space," she said.

Critics, however, called for a complete rethinking of animal shelter
policies to achieve the city's stated no-kill goal.

"Our shelters are failing," said Ed Muzika of the blog LA Animal Watch.
"When you kill 4,000 animals more than last year, it's not success.

He said despite more than 40,000 free spay-neuter vouchers passed out by the
city last year, cat impounds have increased dramatically. He questioned
whether the city's spay-neuter law imposed in October, which requires owners
to fix their pets, may be forcing those who can't afford surgeries to
surrender the animals to city shelters instead.

"In order for no-kill to be realized," said Muzika, "the (department) needs
a top-down analysis by the nation's top no-kill experts."

Because cats are not licensed, Pantoja said, it is more difficult to enforce
a spay-neuter law for felines. A low-cost, community spay-
neuter clinic, Clinico, now operates on the grounds of the San Pedro
shelter.

Davis said it may take three to five years to see results from the city's
spay-neuter ordinance. Meanwhile, she said gradual improvements
are being made.

A nonprofit program to encourage pet owners in South Los Angeles to keep
their pets has saved 800 dogs and cats since January, she said.

And the two-for-one-cat "Summer Buddies" program sponsored by the Found
Animal Foundation at the San Pedro and East Valley shelters and is in effect
through August.
[email protected]
Staff Writer Donna Littlejohn contributed to this article.

Fort Worth City Officials Contact Info:
City Manager Dale Fisseler
Fax: (817) 392-6134
E-mail: [email protected]

Mayor Mike Moncrief
Fax: (817) 392-2409
E-mail: [email protected]

Mayor Pro Tem Kathleen Hicks
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

District 2 Councilman Sal Espino
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

District 3 Councilman W.B. "Zim" Zimmerman
Fax: (817) 392-6187
Email: [email protected]

District 4 Councilman Danny Scarth
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

District 5 Councilman Frank Moss
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

District 6 Councilman Jungus Jordan
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

District 7 Councilman Carter Burdette
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

District 9 Councilman Joel Burns
Fax: (817) 392-6187
E-mail: [email protected]

Brandon Bennett
Fax: (817) 870-2249
E-mail: [email protected]

Keane Menefee
Animal Care and Control
Fax: (817) 561-3741
[email protected]

James Agyemang
Animal Care and Control
Fax: (817) 561-3741
[email protected]

RPOA Texas Outreach (501C4 Nonprofit)
RPOA Texas Outreach
Responsible Pet Owners Alliance (501C3 Nonprofit)
Responsible Pet Owners Alliance - Home

900 NE Loop 410 #311-D
San Antonio, TX 78209
$15 Annual dues (January - December)
To subscribe, contact [email protected]
 

Xandra

Active Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2009
Messages
3,806
Likes
0
Points
36
#2
SURPRISE!!!!

Feel bad for the poor critters though... poor things.
 
Joined
Dec 20, 2003
Messages
94,266
Likes
3
Points
36
Location
Where the selas blooms
#3
Hmmm . . . . like maybe people who can't afford the spay/neuter or the fines are now leaving their animals at large or turning them in, where previously they weren't as irresponsible about keeping them up when in season as the ARistas led the voters to believe.

Add another one to the List of Big Lies.

And another example of what happens whenever government declares a war on some "problem."
 

Criosphynx

New Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
2,242
Likes
0
Points
0
#4
Hmmm . . . . like maybe people who can't afford the spay/neuter or the fines are now leaving their animals at large or turning them in, where previously they weren't as irresponsible about keeping them up when in season as the ARistas led the voters to believe.

Add another one to the List of Big Lies.

And another example of what happens whenever government declares a war on some "problem."

Dont we constantly tell people on this forum (and others) that if people can't afford basic vet care then they should reconsider owning a pet?

If som'one can not legitimantly afford a spay/neuter on a cat how are the cats other needs met?

Having personally walked into Los angeles shelters I can't say im against this law. Its also only enforced on a complaint only basis. Its not like they are scouring the streets looking for unaltered animals. You have to be in violation of another AC law and AC comes out, OR your neighbors have to call and complain.

Unemployment is rising. Cats especially, are considered disposable by people. The rising turn ins are waaaay more likely a product of the economy than this progam. People are dumping all types of pets. I can't tell you how many people on a daily basis try to give me unwanted fish and snakes (which are obviously not affected by spay/neuter laws)

Its way way way to early to label this program a failure.
 
Last edited:

Romy

Taxiderpy
Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Messages
10,233
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Olympia, WA
#5
Dont we constantly tell people on this forum (and others) that if people can't afford basic vet care then they should reconsider owning a pet?

If som'one can not legitimantly afford a spay/neuter on a cat how are the cats other needs met?

Having personally walked into Los angeles shelters I can't say im against this law. Its also only enforced on a complaint only basis. Its not like they are scouring the streets looking for unaltered animals. You have to be in violation of another AC law and AC comes out, OR your neighbors have to call and complain.

Unemployment is rising. Cats especially, are considered disposable by people. The rising turn ins are waaaay more likely a product of the economy than this progam. People are dumping all types of pets. I can't tell you how many people on a daily basis try to give me unwanted fish and snakes (which are obviously not affected by spay/neuter laws)

Its way way way to early to label this program a failure.
One byproduct of this program, that isn't mentioned in the article, is the fact that people who want to keep their animals intact will stop licensing them, and that takes a LOT of money out of ACs pockets that would be going into shelter funding.
 

CaliTerp07

Active Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2008
Messages
7,652
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
38
Location
Alexandria, VA
#6
Dont we constantly tell people on this forum (and others) that if people can't afford basic vet care then they should reconsider owning a pet?

If som'one can not legitimantly afford a spay/neuter on a cat how are the cats other needs met?

Having personally walked into Los angeles shelters I can't say im against this law. Its also only enforced on a complaint only basis. Its not like they are scouring the streets looking for unaltered animals. You have to be in violation of another AC law and AC comes out, OR your neighbors have to call and complain.

Unemployment is rising. Cats especially, are considered disposable by people. The rising turn ins are waaaay more likely a product of the economy than this progam. People are dumping all types of pets. I can't tell you how many people on a daily basis try to give me unwanted fish and snakes (which are obviously not affected by spay/neuter laws)

Its way way way to early to label this program a failure.
:hail:

Wholeheartedly agree. Hell, according to the article spays and neuters were FREE (or at least very very cheap), so the cost of a spay has nothing to do with it. More than likely, the owners are losing their jobs or moving into cheaper apartments that don't allow pets, or are working more hours and don't have time for their dog.

One byproduct of this program, that isn't mentioned in the article, is the fact that people who want to keep their animals intact will stop licensing them, and that takes a LOT of money out of ACs pockets that would be going into shelter funding.
The article said that cats aren't even licensed to begin with, so I can hardly believe the deficit will be that large. Many places the licensing fee for an animal is only $5-10 anyway.

I don't really think it's a funding issue though. Sure, give a shelter a million dollars and they'll be able to build more cages for the cats and dogs...but they'll still have hundreds of cats and dogs coming in. They can hold them longer, but until adoptions>turn ins, money won't solve the problem, just delay it.
 

dmkaiser

New Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2009
Messages
20
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Nevada
#7
i refuse to pay over $200 to have my dog "fixed". his needs are met, he gets fed, toys and vet care, but i can't wrap my mind arounnd trying to find a way to afford to get him altered. he doesn't play with unaltered females because i refuse to be responsible for a litter of pups. there is never going to be an end to over crowded shelters, there are always going to be animals that get dumped. if picking up strays and putting them down will keep disease from running rampant then i'm all for it. life is full of crap and ugly things. the mutts die and get dumped because nobody thinks of them, they aren't purebred so to alot of people they don't matter. it's about companionship when you have a pet, not bragging rights.
 

CaliTerp07

Active Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2008
Messages
7,652
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
38
Location
Alexandria, VA
#8
i refuse to pay over $200 to have my dog "fixed". his needs are met, he gets fed, toys and vet care, but i can't wrap my mind arounnd trying to find a way to afford to get him altered.
There are free clinics in most cities. I know here, in addition to the free place, they sell spay/neuter certificates for $50 at the animal shelter that a number of area vets will take.

It really doesn't have to be expensive.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top