kind of a funny title to this thread...nothing needs to be settled. it's up to the owner and the particular dog. Innova here, supplemented with raw chicken wings/necks/backs daily, and other healthy foods. I try to balance it all, so that they don't overeat..so the kibble to me is a supplement. or, some days the kibble is the main meal...but I always include some of the chicken. they just really love it.
I never eat fat, so they have to eat lean also. I would think with all the dog food battles that rage....it's really rather obvious that it's up to what an idividual feels is best for their dog.
(altho, I really would hope that most would lean towards a healthier kibble after learning more about what's available)