If you order pizza and have extra does it go in the fridge, counter or somewhere else? Growing up we always put it in the fridge, would never even think not to but dh insists it doesn't go in the fridge, it stays in the box. Also, do you reheat your pizza? Dh swears you can't because it changes the consistencey of the chesse, I have to but I do it on the oven rack, never the microwave.