Pet firm fights vet college over euthanasia services
Witness recounts painful death of 15-year-old dog in case against Pet Heaven and its owners
KATE HAMMER February 6, 2009
Maybe all dogs don't go to heaven.
Certainly, Megan McGurk's dog, Jack, went through hell.
After 15 years, a long happy life for a canine, the lab-retriever mix became immobilized and Ms. McGurk contacted a company called Pet Heaven, to have a veterinarian attend her Toronto home to euthanize and then cremate her pet.
But Jack's death was a slow one. He whimpered as the veterinarian injected the Euthanol into his hind leg, and his paws began to jerk as though he were trying to run.
Ms. McGurk recounted his painful death yesterday as a witness in the trial of Pet Heaven and its two owners, Shelley and Eric Blechman, before the Ontario Court of Justice.
The company and both Blechmans have been charged by the College of Veterinarians of Ontario with practising veterinary medicine without a licence and could face fines of up to $55,000.
The Blechmans, a genial couple in their fifties with an enthusiasm for quadrupeds, don't claim to be veterinarians. However, the Veterinarian's Act forbids them from either practising veterinary medicine or offering veterinary services, including euthanasia.
The Blechmans and their lawyer, Michael Pasquale, maintain that they are not offering veterinary services, rather that they are only helping their grief-stricken clients to gain access to a qualified professional who can put their pets to sleep at home, rather than in the sterile environment of a clinic.
"The College of Veterinarians seems to feel that we're acting as veterinarians by arranging for a vet to visit a client's home, which just doesn't make sense," Mr. Blechman said during a court lunch break.
Bernard LeBlanc, a lawyer for the college, pointed to volumes of invoices made out to Pet Heaven for services including euthanasia, and a postcard advertising a "new service" that "provides an alternative to hospital euthanasia."
All of the former clients who appeared in court yesterday, including Ms. McGurk, had their pets euthanized by Grigory Brodetsky, a veterinarian who was also called as a witness.
A large black toolbox at his side, Dr. Brodetsky sat bolt upright in the witness box. His stare darted between Mr. LeBlanc and Justice of the Peace Kevin Madigan.
In rapid, broken English, Dr. Brodetsky denied any association with Pet Heaven, even though records seized by a college investigator showed that he had been paid in excess of $28,000 by the company.
"I told [the Blechmans] not call me, that I don't work for them, I only work for the people," he told the courtroom.
The Blechmans later dismissed suggestions that Dr. Brodetsky was trying to dodge blame or prosecution (client testimony suggested that his euthanasia procedures were clumsy, unorthodox and even harmful). The couple asserted that his testimony must have lost something in translation. (Dr. Brodetsky's native tongue is Russian).
The Blechmans have made a living off sentimentality for nearly five years. Pet Heaven offers cremation services, dog- house-shaped urns, and funeral services for pets. They are fighting the charges because they feel the service they provide is vital to pet owners.
"For every one complaint, there's 300 very happy people who are grateful for what we do," Mr. Blechman said.