Just found this thread today, but I did read through the entire thing and frankly, it's been enlightening and dissappointing at the same time.
Only one comment at the moment:
Just FYI.... my mom was what most of you would probably call a back yard breeder... I helped with three or four litters of BC puppies. Ours were always guarenteed... if for ANY reason you didn't want the dog... we will take the dog back, NO QUESTIONS ASKED. One of ours came back to us because they hadn't figured a 45 pound dog could clear a six foot fence and had had several unknown pregnancies because they also failed to spay her. One out of like 30 isn't too bad though.
I'm glad that you did have a guarantee on your puppies. That's definately the first step towards becoming a good breeder.
Several unknown pregnancies? One, I can understand, maybe they didn't realize how old a dog is when it can become pregnant; so have one litter and then get it spayed. But
several? If she had three litters, and each litter had 8 puppies, that's THIRTY TWO puppies that this dog produced that were most likely out of breed standard, if not mixes. So it's great that you only bred dogs that were in breed standard, but what about the additional 30+ dogs that you also produced that were not breed standard? And I highly doubt this was the only one of your puppies that went on to produce a litter....
I'm saying this not only to try to educate the registered members reading and commenting on this thread, but also to try to educate the other dozens and dozens of lurkers who may never have heard of the difference between a back yard breeder and a reputable breeder.
What do we say about dog trainers who let fights happen in their classes? Or groomers who abuse dogs on their table? Or vets who miss obvious illnesses or give bad advice? We tell you not to go back, and try to educate you on how to find a good dog professional versus a bad one. How is this any different? A breeder's MISSION should be to produce dogs that fit some breed standard and are good representatives of the breed, and then to put those puppies in homes that are also going to respect the breed standard (by not breeding the puppy outside of standard) and help mold that puppy into a good representative. If a breeder doesn't do that, I don't care how cute the puppies are that they produced, we should not be supporting the breeder by giving them money.
I do work in rescue. I go to shelters at least once a month, and the dogs I train 40 hours a week are all shelter/rescue dogs. When I go into a shelter to evaluate dogs for our program, I will look at at least 500 dogs before I find one to bring home. I look 500 dogs in the eye and tell them that they have to stay here in this filthy, tiny cage because someone ignorant put them there. I know what it's like to say no.
The other day I saw a truck parked on the side of the road with a "Chihuahuas for sale" sign, and I broke down and cried. It's certainly not the first truck on the side of the road I've seen (and it wasn't the only one in that parking lot, either!), but I guess it hit me harder because I have a chi, and I said no to three adorable chis in the shelter the week before. I cried, but did I turn my car around? Pull into the parking lot and go see the puppies? Ask the guy how much? NO! That's how you say no - you just turn away and keep driving!