Didn't read thru every post so I'm not sure what's been suggested, but I use Whiska Lickin's for Gage, and Deli-Cat treats too. I use them for Emmy as well, because she has an extremely tiny mouth and it's hard for her to chew bigger or hard treats when training. I also cut up a Canine Carry-Out treat into tiny little pieces, and use that as well for training with her and Gage. I find them soft, and easy to chew.