I was wondering how many of you have a household with both large and small dogs? We were always planning on getting a larger dog, and Megan kind of fell into my lap. I adore her, and may get another Papillon at some point, but I always wanted to have a larger breed as well. (One of my favorites is the Doberman) Can you live in harmony with both, or would it be dangerous for Megan? BTW, she is probably going to be about 7 pounds at maturity, and we plan on doing some advanced obedience with her, so she should have some manners. Any thoughts??
Big & Little Dog Families??
- Thread starter Megansmom
- Start date
- Joined
- May 30, 2008
- Messages
- 556
- Likes
- 0
- Points
- 0
When Cali was still around(st. bernard), she and my sheltie Peaches got along wonderfully(Peaches is small for a sheltie, about 15 pounds at her lightest).
At this time two Collies above 60 pounds, and a 50+ pound 18 week old st. bernard puppy...Peaches is still doing fine
. I think you would be alright, but again...it depends on the individual dogs. I know some large dogs do not like small dogs, and vis versa.
At this time two Collies above 60 pounds, and a 50+ pound 18 week old st. bernard puppy...Peaches is still doing fine
. I think you would be alright, but again...it depends on the individual dogs. I know some large dogs do not like small dogs, and vis versa.
We only have small dogs currently (2 1/2-18 pounds). But we did have a large dog (A husky mix about 70-80 pounds). But she ended up out of no where killing two of our dogs and my mother won't allow another big dog in her home with the small dogs. I can probably talk her out of it someday when we don't have very many dogs in general. But I do take some of our dogs to the dog park, and they are perfectly okay with large dogs (At first they were terrified of them!)
- Joined
- Apr 25, 2006
- Messages
- 2,947
- Likes
- 0
- Points
- 36
I can't say I've *never* had a problem, but it wasn't a problem that couldn't be managed. My very big dogs have always, for the most part, done well with very little dogs, cats, rodents, etc.
But as mentioned previously, it really depends on the dog. Even the breed. I wouldn't get a breed that's reknowned for it's intense prey drive if I had smaller pets in the home that resembled prey. I know some make it work, but I don't like to live on the edge.
But as mentioned previously, it really depends on the dog. Even the breed. I wouldn't get a breed that's reknowned for it's intense prey drive if I had smaller pets in the home that resembled prey. I know some make it work, but I don't like to live on the edge.
I have to agree with the "depends on the dogs" comment, whether it be big or small.
I've always wanted a standard poodle and will someday but not until my smallest little one is no longer with me. In my experience in the past with fostering a standard it was an accident waiting to happen. Not due to the standard poodle, she was a gentle gale, but with Kassie, my 3 pound toy poodle.
Kassie's to bossy around other dogs and likes to stand her ground. She's not mean with other dogs but when all the dogs would get excited about something, like the door bell ringing, they'd all head towards their interest and Kassie would stand in the middle and not budge and in more then one occasion Kassie would get barreled over by the standard. It almost happened with her falling down the stairs.
So no big dogs in here for now.
I've always wanted a standard poodle and will someday but not until my smallest little one is no longer with me. In my experience in the past with fostering a standard it was an accident waiting to happen. Not due to the standard poodle, she was a gentle gale, but with Kassie, my 3 pound toy poodle.
Kassie's to bossy around other dogs and likes to stand her ground. She's not mean with other dogs but when all the dogs would get excited about something, like the door bell ringing, they'd all head towards their interest and Kassie would stand in the middle and not budge and in more then one occasion Kassie would get barreled over by the standard. It almost happened with her falling down the stairs.
So no big dogs in here for now.
We had a member with a bull mastiff and Chihuahua see the video on post #7 it's cute and shows how a big dog can learn to adapt to play well with a small dog: http://www.chazhound.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55376
I have a dobe and a miniature poodle... granted, the doberman is small for breed standard and the miniature poodle is.. well... uhmm fat, lol... but they get along..
The only problem is, the poodle is 10 years old, and just likes to lay and sleep all day, while the doberman is still very very much a puppy, very hyper and she just doesnt seem to understand completely that the poodle just isnt interested in playing.
The only problem is, the poodle is 10 years old, and just likes to lay and sleep all day, while the doberman is still very very much a puppy, very hyper and she just doesnt seem to understand completely that the poodle just isnt interested in playing.
I have a 60 lb Golden mix, he is tall though.... 3 Jrts all about 15 lbs and Molly who only weighs about 3 lbs...
They all do well, Foster is VERY cute when he plays with Molly as he "tames" it down..... compared to when he roughhouses with his bestest buddy Max.... I would say actually that I watch my Jrts with Molly more so that the big guy!!
They all do well, Foster is VERY cute when he plays with Molly as he "tames" it down..... compared to when he roughhouses with his bestest buddy Max.... I would say actually that I watch my Jrts with Molly more so that the big guy!!
This is Sophie and Daisy, Sophie in her prime was over 40kg, Daisy never went past 5kg. They were best friends till the end, Sophie hasn't been quite the same since Daisy died. They're games used to involve Sophie running as fast as she could in huge circles, tail tucked in, smile on her face, away from this little ball of fluff tearing after her, you had to see it, it was the funniest thing to watch
Daisy looks bigger than she is in this pic, when she was clipped off she was smaller than our cat.
I also know someone on another forum that has a mini dachsund, its best friend is a bullmastiff, they are so gorgeous together
I think it can be done. In future I would lke a dane, a bullmastiff and a pug. I would probably seperate when unsupervised untill the large dog had matured enough not to leap at the small dog anf hurt it accidentally
Daisy looks bigger than she is in this pic, when she was clipped off she was smaller than our cat.
I also know someone on another forum that has a mini dachsund, its best friend is a bullmastiff, they are so gorgeous together
I think it can be done. In future I would lke a dane, a bullmastiff and a pug. I would probably seperate when unsupervised untill the large dog had matured enough not to leap at the small dog anf hurt it accidentally
I'm planning on getting a BC in the future, but I'm really thinking this through.
Summer is 6 lbs and her safety always comes first. Border collies aren't too big, but there will be a size difference.
I wanted an older BC but now I'm thinking a puppy may be the best bet. And maybe even one that I know the background of. I want a rescue but really with such a little dog it may be best to know for sure what you're getting. Some of the working border collie lines are smaller and may be a better choice.
I do know a lot of people with paps and large dogs and it can be done. It takes supervision, though.
I will tell you though that papillons are terribly breedist and will bond best with other papillons. (Though Beau seems to have a thing for Japanese Chin too....)
Summer is 6 lbs and her safety always comes first. Border collies aren't too big, but there will be a size difference.
I wanted an older BC but now I'm thinking a puppy may be the best bet. And maybe even one that I know the background of. I want a rescue but really with such a little dog it may be best to know for sure what you're getting. Some of the working border collie lines are smaller and may be a better choice.
I do know a lot of people with paps and large dogs and it can be done. It takes supervision, though.
I will tell you though that papillons are terribly breedist and will bond best with other papillons. (Though Beau seems to have a thing for Japanese Chin too....)