A fresh view of an old relationship.

Promethean

New Member
Joined
May 22, 2009
Messages
33
Likes
0
Points
0
#1
http://www.coape.org/cpd51.html

THE MEXICO CITY DUMP - AN ISLAND PARADISE OF DOGS
A fresh view of an old relationship.

24th April 2010
The Medieval Hall, Cathedral Close, Salisbury, Wiltshire
Written and presented by Professor Ray Coppinger.

I like watching dogs. I mostly like watching "islands" of dogs. The concept of “island†is to try to limit the area of study. On a real island a dog population will stop at the water’s edge. Within that well-defined area the dogs will find food, reproduce and try to stay out of trouble. How they do that is what I like to watch.

Now — picture a large city, Mexico City, perhaps the largest city in the world. Millions and millions of people are eating every day in this city, creating enormous waste. Those wastes are collected and delivered directly to the dogs in the dump. It is just like feeding pets but on a much bigger scale.

“All species of animals are limited by foodâ€, says Darwin. Finding enough food to keep body and soul together, reproduce and stay out of trouble is what natural selection is all about. But if Charlie had studied the dogs in the Mexico City dump he might not have come up with his theory.

For most dogs in the world their daily bread is reliable. The Mexico City dump dogs have a 24/7/365 reliable resource just like our better-cared-for pets. Life is so much better and more natural for the dump dogs. All the food you can eat and an interesting social life which is heavy into courtship, motherhood and puppies and all those other wonderful natural things that dogs like to do. In fact for a dog it is a bit of paradise. They are not neutered, and they are not on a leash.
 
Last edited:

Promethean

New Member
Joined
May 22, 2009
Messages
33
Likes
0
Points
0
#3
....they do not get veterinary care, they act as a vector for diseases....
According to other studies, they are pretty healthy. Many dogs don't get vet care, even in NA, so what's your point. And do you have any documentation that these dogs are transmitting diseases?
 

Doberluv

Active Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Messages
22,038
Likes
2
Points
38
Location
western Wa
#4
“All species of animals are limited by food”, says Darwin. Finding enough food to keep body and soul together, reproduce and stay out of trouble is what natural selection is all about. But if Charlie had studied the dogs in the Mexico City dump he might not have come up with his theory.
I think his theory is still applicable. He didn't need to study those dogs. Those dogs or possibly wolves or other dog-like animal (before the dogs) that started out being able to eat in close proximatey to humans were thereby selected to fare better in a human settlement. Those that were less afraid of humans thrived and reproduced better in a human niche than those that did not come and feed at the dumps. They got tamer and tamer. The others may have branched off and gone on a different evolutionary path.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top