Why don't they let you neuter/spay a show dog?

Discussion in 'Dogs - General Dog Chat' started by misticaleclipse, Nov 7, 2006.

  1. Laurelin

    Laurelin I'm All Ears

    Nov 2, 2006
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    a lot
    Home Page:

    Well, I meant with breeds like shelties, coat does matter. they were bred in a very cold environment so a double coat is needed for insulation. In paps, it really is just for beauty, but I basically treat it like anything on the standard. You try to better it. It says a single coat that is silky to the touch, so it'd be wrong to have a double coated, coarse haired papillon. Most of the papillon standard just revolves around the 'buttefly' appearance. Ex: colored markings. Paps must have color on both ears and over both eyes. A symmetrical blaze is preffered. But in this case, the American breeders are a WHOLE lot more lenient than the English breeders. Solid headed dogs and crookedly blazed dogs are shown a lot in the akc and bred. (An in Sweden and many other countries) It's a major rift in the american and english breeders right now. English breeders actually focus on thicker coats than American breeders and they focus more on markings- less color on the body and a bigger, straighter blaze. Imo the markings really don't matter a whole lot. In fact, breeding for bigger blazes makes mismarks (ie: a papillon with white over one eye or white on an ear, even half colored faces similar to a jrt) a whole lot more prevalent. English breeders are having some problems now breeding non dqed dogs in these lines that carry these huge blazes. So it's not really just the akc that has problems like this, it's all registries.

    However, in papillons and companion breeds, soundness really does apply still even if the breed isn't working. You don't want to breed dogs that have hip or eye problems no matter what they do.

    IMO it's not the AKC that ruins breeds, but it's the breeders. People interpret standards differently. If you actually compare the AKC to FCI and other standards, they're really very similar. It's just the type the breeders choose to go after and what attributes they feel like accentuating.
  2. Cole's Mom

    Cole's Mom Dobe Lover

    Oct 1, 2006
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Actually, the AKC does not write the breed standards. The parent club of the breed writes the standards and submits them to the AKC. Breeders breed what they think is close to what the standard asks for or some breed to what they think will win in the ring.

    Coat, bite, missing teeth, angulation, movement, temperament all have an impact on how a dog performs the tasks they were bred for. Of course it differs by breed, but I do not think you can say that these things are of no consequence.

    Cole's Mom
    CH. Joric's Bold Venture Msmar, ROM, CD, WAC, CGC

Share This Page