Okay, so the grrls are doing very well on Canidae, but.... (you knew there was a but coming lol) I liked Maddie's coat better when it was on EVO. She has a little bit of dandruff right now, and some eye goopies. I don't remember this much eye goopies with the EVO... And the texture of her hair has changed a teensy bit, I'm not sure how to explain it really. Less soft, I guess. My problem - the only store that carries EVO in the area started to sell designer breed puppies at their store. And, of course, I refuse to shop their anymore! Missy is doing really well on Canidae, however. And since I live with my parents, and they also feed Canidae we just buy a big bag and split... I'm considering buying a bag of TOTW and seeing how Maddie does on it - because its grain free. And if Missy likes it, maybe her too (she's a picky eater). I've read the ingredients, and they look good to me - but I'd love some input! Thx!