I wasn't even going to go here. But hey, you wanted to play the victim card so here we go.
It may not be your fault that he has to go outside, we've all had parents/homes and rules about pets we didn't agree with, and It's nice that he's helping you with depression, but YOU MADE THE CHOICE to get him. You really aren't the poor victim here. I don't think "he makes me feel better" is a good reason. NOBODY FORCED THIS PUPPY ON YOU.
We've had situation here on chaz of parents bringing home pups and enforcing rules on members and you know.. I have more compassion for that kind of situation than I do an adult, KNOWING THE RULES, who has had dogs before where the rules were enforced, going out and getting a puppy.
Sometimes being an adult means putting our wants behind what is best for the animals we choose to bring into our lives.
and I don't think that's what you did here at all. You wanted this dog, you got him, FAIR ENOUGH, we all do selfish things sometimes, I've gotten dogs I wasn't ready for (they don't live outside in kennels now, but I digress) but it still makes these pictures for me, INCREDIBLY SAD.
I can't look at this happy puppy and not think of him crying in that kennel come spring time, sad lonely and confused.
or better yet, think of that other dog of yours who is out there now while this puppy is comfortable in the house.
So no, in my opinion, I don't think you should've gotten him. I don't think "he makes me feel better" is a good enough reason to bring an innocent puppy into your home to then toss him outside in a kennel come spring to be taken out when the weather is right and the stars align and when you feel like paying attention to him.
If my only option was to get a puppy (that I really wanted, even if it was Merlin my dream dog) and knowing that AT SOME POINT, any point in his life he would have to live in a kennel outside alone.. I wouldn't get him.
If I had to put Merlin in a kennel outside tomorrow to live, he would be back at his breeders looking for a new home. No matter how much it would break my heart. I couldn't do that to him.
but hey that's just me.
I understand wanting a puppy.
I understand puppies are very comforting.
They are also very exciting and new.
Grief over lost pets is very real and does hurt.
I TOTALLY get the impulse and why you would want one.
and I don't think you meant any harm
that said, that doesn't make this puppies outlook any less sad.
And it isn't really 100% about the kennel, to be clear, this isn't a hunting dog that is getting out to do a job everyday, or with a pack of other dogs, or with space to roam. It's more about dogs, pack animals, being left out, alone, in a kennel outside, for convenience sake.
So yea, even though dogs are adaptable, and it's not abuse... there's my 2 cents.
and perhaps some perspective as to why maybe some people aren't all "awww" over these pictures.