Ok so I am making SOME progress with Lily with housebreaking. I have been letting her play fifteen minutes and then crating her fifteen minutes and then taking her outside to go potty and she is doing good that way. She had one accident today but that is because I totally lost track of time and she hadn't been outside for half an hour so she went in on the floor. This has really made me realize how different each puppy is to housebreak. I thought I had it ALL figured out. I'll get it, we'll both get it together.