Cropping ears at home.

Doberluv

Active Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Messages
22,038
Likes
2
Points
38
Location
western Wa
#41
I've seen dogs who did show discomfort
Why? What materials were used? What kind of positive reinforcement was used? There is no reason for this to be miserable to any dog. I belong to a Doberman board with many experienced Dobe owners, some breeders, some who have had Dobes for 35 years or more. We've had these discussions, of course....people asking questions or needing help with posting. And what I have gathered from the vast majority of these Doberman people (and there are a lot) is just how I described my experience with my Doberman....many of them sleeping right through it, playing as usual, no discomfort at all. The only times it was not pleasant were the few times where Lyric didn't feel like holding still and wanted to go play or something was distracting him, like another dog. Then it was disappointing to him to have to hold still for the 2 minutes per ear that it took for me to post him up. LOL. But that's the same thing as when I have to do nails. "Gosh, do I have to?" It's no more uncomfortable than having to sit still and get their nails clipped or Dremelled. I think a lot of people make it more complicated than it needs to be by using poor choices of materials (too sticky tape, hard things in the ears, doing a sloppy, loose job) and their own attitude being passed onto the dog..."this is sooooooo horrible to do." Projecting human, complicated stuff onto the dogs.
 

silverpawz

No Sugar Added
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Messages
587
Likes
0
Points
0
#42
The discomfort was shown by shaking their head repeatedly, pawing at their ears and generally sulking. I doubt the dogs were in PAIN, but they were bothered by it none the less. In terms of positive rienforcement, the standard 'associate this with something good' procedure was done.

I just don't personaly see a good reason to do it. Even if every dog had zero problems with it, I still wouldn't want to see it done. Plus, I prefer the look of an uncropped dog.
 

mamasobuco

New Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2006
Messages
381
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Cleveland, Ohio
#43
I appologize. Because your post came right after mine asking about why a Chi's ears would need cropping, I mistakenly associated with that context. I sure would never trash your grandfather or anyone way back in those days for doing what they needed to do when there probably weren't a bunch of veterinarians around. It was probably one of those newer professions just coming about. You're right about education though. That's for sure. Thanks for clearing that up. I didn't want you to think that I thought ill of or disrespect for your grandfather.
No need to apologize. After I saw your post I reread mine and completely understood why you thought that. Again, I'm sorry for that.
 

Doberluv

Active Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Messages
22,038
Likes
2
Points
38
Location
western Wa
#44
No problem Mamasobuco. I feel kind of stupid. Sometimes I'm just a little jumpy. LOL.

Well, Silverpaws, you're right. It's not better than not doing anything to their ears. But it's certainly not the abuse that people make it out to be and most people prefer the cropped Doberman, in this country anyhow.

There are purposes or functions for it, albeit not hugely important, I guess. I know my dogs never get ear ifections from yeast like my Lab did and some of my floppy earred mixes. She had yeast over growth almost constantly and was regularily on Ottomax. My GSDs, my Chi's and my Dobe have never once had an infeciton. My Lab went deaf and she wasn't even all that old yet. I wonder if those infections had something to do with it. There is something about the air circulation, something about the cone of hearing with upright ears. The pinpointing of direction is much more accurate and hearing in general more keen with upright ears. This has been studied and demonstrated. For a dog who is bred for protection, this is no small attribute. It's easier to see which exact direction my dog is alerting to. It plays a role in his job.

And yes, I'll admit, I do love the look of an alert, tight fitting Doberman and cropped ears and a docked tail adds to this look...no appendages sticking out for anyone to grab or hurt or to interfer with the dog's job. If I got a rescue who didn't have cropped ears, I'd love it just as much and he'd still be a Doberman. But when given the choice with a puppy, I'd go for the cropped. Actually reputable breeders in this country at any rate always crop their ears. There is no choice in the majority of cases. They want their dogs to represent the breed in the traditional way, I guess.

But it is personal preferrence as far as how one likes them to look or function. And it should remain personal choice because it is not abuse. People really should get off of this and if they're so concerned about animal welfare, they should do something to help animals in real trouble. There are a lot more of those in this world.
 
Joined
Jul 17, 2005
Messages
5,634
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
35
Location
Ontario, Canada
#45
Here, Here Carrie!!!! I don''t understand how people can''t see and understand the true function of a good crop. I mean I totally understand and respect not wanting to get it done in one''s own dog but one should first at least thoroughly examine the benefits of a good crop (and dock for that matter) including discussing with a good reputable vet along with the breeder the procedure, after care and rate of recovery and how it seems to effect the puppies before making a final conclusion about the whole cropping issue. They may be surprised what they would learn!!! I myself have been converted from "I agree with it so long as it is done by someone reputable, but it is not for me" to "Yes I agree with it so long as it is done by someone reputable and all my dogs who should be cropped will be!" thanks to simply taking the time to educate myself and talking to those with cropped and uncropped dogs and comparing them to eachother.
 

2nd2none

New Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2006
Messages
153
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Boston, MA. (north shore)
#46
IMO, there are no health benefits and it's a procedure done based on human emotion, and that's it. A dogs' ears should be left as nature intended.I'm glad more and more vets are refusing to do croppings, and quite happy the ones I work for don't agree with it either.
Sorry, flame me all you want, but I personally think it's a VERY selfish human decision. PERIOD!!!
and happily, that thread on Game-Dogs was closed.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
2,947
Likes
0
Points
36
#47
I don't crop. I cropped my first dane, and cried about it as soon as I picked him up from the vet. His tender pink ears were cut, red, and angry looking. He cried when I touched his head because he was afraid I would hurt them. I had to keep him away from the other dogs because he would yelp if they came near him because he was afraid they'd bump him. He ran from me when it was taping time. Finally, after a few months, I just said forget it. His ears never stood, but I don't care, I just hate that I did it.

Now, I'm not judging people that DO crop. What irks me though is that people claim it's for health reasons (I'm talking about pets....a dog that works is obviously a different can of beans). Dane folks will argue pro cropping all day based on "they might get ear infections or hematomas if they're not cropped". If that's the case, then why aren't bassets and cockers cropped? Those breeds take the cake for infections. And I've seen more German Shepherds with hematomas than I have uncropped danes. If you like the look of cropped ears, that's fine, just say it.

My other reason for not cropping any more is this:



That head is gorgeous just the way it is. And I love those soft flappy ears! :)

Now on to the subject of cropping at home - some breeders have veterinarians come to their home to crop puppies. It saves the puppies from being exposed to viruses at the hospital. But again, this is a veterinarian...not some dude with a litter of pups and a pair of scissors. That's just wrong.
 

squirtsmom

New Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2006
Messages
3,242
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Missouri
#48
To Shadowfacedanes, that is one awesome looking great dane. Just adorable. Honestly, did not think there would be such a time on the forum for this post. Thanks to all who posted.
 

joce

Active Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2005
Messages
4,448
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
40
Location
Ohio
#49
Breeds that need it like bassest etc ears are to vascular to do it safely or they probally would. Instead when those dogs are prone to them they do things like tie there ears up for so long per day or with cockers remove the inner ear so the dog is deaf but no longer suffers from ear infections. I'll never forget the basset across the street running around all day with his ears tied up on his head:p

Danes are one breed I probally would not crop but only because it seems to take sooo long for there ears to stand and I see so many that never do stand even when the owners put all there effort into it.My moms friend bred when I was younger and she kept them till they began to show so she would be doing ears on like eight pups and thats all she ever did when I was over there. byrons ears were a snap compared to that.

I also consider all of my dogs working dogs. if they didn't have a job I woudln't have gotten them. they may not do exactly what they were bred for but running around on a bunch of farms isn't safe for any loose appendages. My husky had her tail broke as a pup and she is seven now and I still cna not touch her tail. All of her is pretty and brushed but her big ratty tail:p
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
#50
I don't crop. I cropped my first dane, and cried about it as soon as I picked him up from the vet. His tender pink ears were cut, red, and angry looking. He cried when I touched his head because he was afraid I would hurt them. I had to keep him away from the other dogs because he would yelp if they came near him because he was afraid they'd bump him. He ran from me when it was taping time. Finally, after a few months, I just said forget it. His ears never stood, but I don't care, I just hate that I did it.

Now, I'm not judging people that DO crop. What irks me though is that people claim it's for health reasons (I'm talking about pets....a dog that works is obviously a different can of beans). Dane folks will argue pro cropping all day based on "they might get ear infections or hematomas if they're not cropped". If that's the case, then why aren't bassets and cockers cropped? Those breeds take the cake for infections. And I've seen more German Shepherds with hematomas than I have uncropped danes. If you like the look of cropped ears, that's fine, just say it.

My other reason for not cropping any more is this:



That head is gorgeous just the way it is. And I love those soft flappy ears! :)

Now on to the subject of cropping at home - some breeders have veterinarians come to their home to crop puppies. It saves the puppies from being exposed to viruses at the hospital. But again, this is a veterinarian...not some dude with a litter of pups and a pair of scissors. That's just wrong.
smooches for each of those gorgous ears!!!!!!!!!! They are just devine.:hail:

I still want to do my ears montage to the tune of HAIR i just don't know how. I had my ear pierced when the kids were little up in the cartiledge. That lasts all of one afternoon before i said this is insane, it hurts and what in the world was i thinking. I took it out, and it is still tender in that spot a decade later. I can't see cartlidge being cut in an animal any different. Besides looking at cropped ears makes my stomach queesy (sp?).
 
Joined
Jul 17, 2005
Messages
5,634
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
35
Location
Ontario, Canada
#51
As I already stated cropping in certain breeds started because of other reasons and the health benefits are simply a bonus which stirs some breeders and owners to continue the tradition even in their pets. Bassets never got cropped because their long ears are what help them be able to scent so well by "channeling" scents into their nose. If people were to crop the ears that would kind of defeat the purpose of having the long droopy ears to begin with.

That being said though it''s not like I think badly about someone who doesn''t crop. I think your Great Dane is gorgeous with his/her natural ears. It''s all a matter of choice. i just wish that those dont agree with cropping dont look down upon those of us who do agree with it or do it like we are some evil dog-hating hellion. Not saying that you do but simply in general. Some choose to crop, others don''t, big deal.

By the way I couldn''t help but notice that it sounds like your first dane you cropped you had it done after you picked him up from the breeders? That would mean he was likely over 8 weeks already, correct? Are croppings not typically done MUCH younger than 8 weeks when the cartilidge is even softer?
 

SizzleDog

Lord Cynical
Joined
Nov 12, 2004
Messages
9,449
Likes
0
Points
0
#52
It's the tapeing afterward to 'train' the ears that I think bothers the dogs more than the actual procedure. I've seen some poor dogs taped up for a LONG time and I just can't imagine how annoying and uncomforable that has to be...all just so they'd look a certain way.
May I ask... are you female? The best way to explain ear posting is that it parallels bras. If you are female, I bet the first time you wore a bra you were miserable... it was probably tight, itchy, constricting... I bet you couldn't wait to rip it off at the end of the day!

But after a few days, I bet the bra bothered you less and less. Heck, I'm guessing (if you're female) that you're wearing one right now and it isn't bothering you in the slightest - I'm guessing you completely forgot about it until I brought up the subject.

The same seems to apply to dogs with posted ears. Yes, it feels funky the first couple times, but after awhile the dog gets used to the posts... they forget about them, just like women forget about their bras 10 seconds after they're put on.

I've had multiple cropped puppies in my home (all, might I add, done by one of the most acclaimed cropping vets in the country). I know how to tape ears properly, and none of the pups I've taped have ever acted like they even notice the posts.
 

silverpawz

No Sugar Added
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Messages
587
Likes
0
Points
0
#53
Sizzle, yes I'm female and I hate the feeling of my underwire, but I still wear one! :D

Like I said before, I just don't see a good reason for it. Doesn't mean I think it's terrible that you or anyone else here cropped, but I still don't agree with it. It's not required and I'm not the kind of person to want elective procedures done on my pets just for the sake of having it done. If you want to do it then have at it, that's your right.
 

SizzleDog

Lord Cynical
Joined
Nov 12, 2004
Messages
9,449
Likes
0
Points
0
#54
I totally agree, people are welcome to have their own opinions. I was just trying to dispel the assumption that posted puppies are in constant misery - they really do forget about the posts quickly - as long as the puppy is properly posted! ;)

I'm of the opinion that no crop is better than a bad crop any day. Both of mine have great crops, but you can be sure that they'd have natural ears if I hadn't gotten them from a responsible breeder who has a great cropper crop her puppies.
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2006
Messages
1,743
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Niagara NY
#55
Some missconceptions the working dog 'crop" on my breed is a amputation of the total ear flap at 3 days not a constructed crop at 8 weeks.

The ears do get ripped allot in working LGD dogs .
Ear infections are much less but a bad crop can cause a bad ear infection as well. I have a 10 year old that has chronic ear infections due to a bad job on her ears, i have a bad crop done by a Vet that resulted in too much ear and the wanna bees in show world use that as a way to attack the dog.
I could of put him under the knife and i said NO and endured years of ribbing from competition about his bad ears.

The one dog i have with big ears gets horribly ripped when he is working.

It is a personal choice and i have owners who wants ears for their pets.

I show my dogs and work them last time I entered that eared dog into a show over the winter he got into it with feral dogs and I lost my entry fee and my hotel dep for the nite....

So again just personal choices.

My avatar has the classsic correct crop..
 

Boemy

New Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2006
Messages
2,481
Likes
0
Points
0
#56
I don't see any point to it. I think a lot of times it was started so a dog would look "mean" and sometimes just for fashion. People used to crop dalmations' ears, for crying out loud. I can see the point in tail docking in some breeds, but not ear cropping.

On a different note, I'll bet Paris Hilton's next big fad will be to buy a labrador and have a heart or flower design punched out of the middle of its ear.
 
Joined
Apr 6, 2006
Messages
1,743
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Niagara NY
#58
Yes I agree some of the Pit crops can give impressions of meaness when it is normally on a sweet dog..

My breed looks more goofy with them but it does not make them look mean to have the ear flap removed...
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
2,947
Likes
0
Points
36
#59
By the way I couldn''t help but notice that it sounds like your first dane you cropped you had it done after you picked him up from the breeders? That would mean he was likely over 8 weeks already, correct? Are croppings not typically done MUCH younger than 8 weeks when the cartilidge is even softer?
He was 8 1/2 weeks old. Most danes are cropped between 7 - 10 weeks of age, depending on weight.
 

Rubylove

Training the Trainer
Joined
Jul 4, 2005
Messages
1,059
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
49
Location
Lovely sunny Perth! :-)
#60
Ha - anyone who has to wear a bra knows that they suck worse than anything and although you get used to it you never like it or want to wear one. It's just a necessity. If someone could come up with something different they'd be a trillionaire in seconds!!

Now, back to the original topic, sorry....
 

Members online

Top