We had this discussion early today, actually. lol
From strictly the show POV, some thought why Hershel? In that moment, why him and not Michonne? You know he'd want her to suffer... I have my opinions on this, but I'll share later.
I will miss Hershel. I was like :yikes: but calmed down during that lame talking dead and I knew it was time. Sadface
I'm on the fence about Judith. I re-watched the episode, and the car seat
was unbuckled, but there is a lot of blood. You know what happens in the comic..... But there are differences all along. I still wish Carl killed Shane....
I think it'll be interesting if Judith lives, how will they keep her quiet? Since the biters are attracted to noise. Where exactly will they go? Will there be separate story lines for a bit? Will they give us an answer about the rats? Yuck.
And the sneak preview from February... Eek... Looked like a direct scene from the comic! Can't wait ! Also can't wait for the new characters to be introduced from the comic