Obedience and Rally O training

Red.Apricot

Active Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
2,984
Likes
2
Points
38
Location
Southern California
#21
I started buckling down on Elsie's heeling last week. When she's on, she's GORGEOUS. But, unfortunately (because I'm lazy) she'd heel reliably for about a minute before wandering.

So, now I'm working on making heeling super rewarding to her, and on extending the behavior for a lot longer period of time.

She's already getting snappier.

Oh and I've been trying to get her to 'spring off the line' as it were, because she was lagging a bit on the first couple steps no matter what else I tried, so I'm trying to make jumping up as soon as I say lets-go (rather than waiting until I've already taken a step) part of the behavior, and so far that's working well, too.

I'm also actively seeking out more distracting environments for us to practice heeling in, because we both need it.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
#22
Ok, here it is, I finally did it, so you all better show up now! :rofl1:

I'll start! I've got Mackenzy, 7 yrs old. She has her CD and RA, and one leg of her CDX. We're holding off on further trialing to get some foundation issues straightened out.

And then there's the Keeva, she's a baby with no titles, and we're going make sure we're very, very ready before we go in the ring because I'd like to pull high scores ideally.

So, what I'd love thoughts on are two issues Mackenzy is having:

1.) Slow down on recall. She always does it, and she always does it well enough to Q but it's slower than I'd like. Keeva has a "dig front nails in and slam down" down in motion, Macky creeps. I've done a lot of fast "chase me and then DOWN!" games, and lots of DIM (down in motion, from here on out) while heeling practice.
I always imprint a recall by tossing a ball or food between my legs so they get used to running thru me. after a lot of that it makes for some interesting fronts when I don't toss one thru :) but if I time it right in the beginning I can save my family jewels some hardship with a hard sit and some hand help. This of course slows them down again a bit because the game has changed a bit, but once the realize that sometimes the ball is getting tossed thru at the last second, sometimes it's sit and it gets tossed thru or any other number of good things that can happen there, the speed is there and consistent thru to the front position. At least it always has been for me.
2.) Some dumbbell issues... She will often wait for a second cue to take her dumbbell, or want me to "help" her with my body. I would LOVE any suggestions for this one, as well as some ideas on increasing her enthusiasm in general. Her enthusiasm isn't bad (moves at a brisk trot) but I'd love it to be better!
Stop helping her :) Stepping towards and pointing is help as i'm sure you know, fade it. Just small points or steps, then just give the object a hard stare, then a glance and give her some time to figure it out. Patience is good here.

for making it more enthusiastic, make it a game. I always train fronts, "take it", holds, etc seperately. My dogs are easily in drive, i pretty much just have to breath, but I use toys at first, toss one, tell them to "take it" or "get it" and as soon as they do I mark and toss a different one. Increases speed and enthusiasm for the toy. After my hold and dumbell is good, I'll use that. Toss it, take it, when they do, immediately mark and reward with food or ball.

and where ever they drop it is fine, after they get reward from me, I tell them to "take it" again and at first they're a bit confused, but soon the immediately race back to the dumbell, I mark when they pick it up and reward again.

moving on, they have to do more, grab and start running back, grab and come to front. At this point I might toss it, tell them to take it, mark when they're almost to a front and reward, and then do a short heeling away and tell them to take it again, then mark/reward as soon as they touch it, then do some tug play and pull them away from the DB and them tell them to get it again and come to front before I mark/play. But I only toss it once, the rest of the time they're dropping it and i'm moving them away with play or heeling and they have to go back and get it when I say.

this can cause them to drop it early and things, but you have to balance that later and don't let them get away with dropping it before you mark and reward. if they anticipate the reward, i just give a verbal "ah" and "get it" and back to the game. It's fun, it's fast, and then it's done. Easier to demonstrate than type. Does it make sense?


Now, with Keeva, and again, I'd kill for your thoughts, things are going really well aside from her distractible baby brain, but, she's uncomfortable with the "fast" portion of heeling - totally thinks I'm going to step on her, and swings really wide so she can watch me. Again, halps?

Alright, now it's your turn with suggestions and your own issues/triumphs. Like I said, you'd better show up! :D

I should have some video up later today.
My response is in red
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
#23
Oh! I can start with a question... How does everyone teach "front?"
I imprint with two hands of food and get them pushing into me to get it. Then gradually as they're pushing I lure them to a sit and draw them closer with body language and get to the point I can fade the food lures and both hands at the side and get eye contact before rewarding.

At first though a lot of just pushing into me and food up close. Later it's a lot of manipulation to get them straight and lots of short, short recalls, like 2 steps and reinforce the up close, straight, eye contact front.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
#24
Have you ever seen Petra Ford, with her amazing Lab, Tyler? Two times National Obedience Champion.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rv4izoPcvCA

The dog is incredible. And he's a field-bred Lab, with drive oozing out of him. .
It's a nice routine, but I wouldn't call it oozing with drive by any means. I've seen plenty of IPO dogs that aren't very drivey in OB too, but I wouldn't call that a drivey routine.
 

Sekah

The Monster.
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
1,339
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Toronto
#25
Cohen is my first performance dog, and I'm trying to do a little bit of everything with her. Unfortunately for her, she's my guinea pig -- I'm making loads of first timer mistakes with her. Fortunately for me, she's pretty forgiving. She has her CD and her RA and a leg towards her RE. We've never NQd during an obedience sport run, but I'm a perfectionist and opted to take some time off from competition until I could get a few drive issues sorted out.

Cohen can get really flat in the ring, so I've been reading a lot about play via Denise Fenzi and I'm planning on taking some private lessons with a new obedience instructor but I haven't made the appointments yet. I think I've fallen into a fairly common trap where I rely too heavily on food and other constant reinforcement so when the motivation isn't there the performance suffers.

I think I'll not bother taking Cohen any further than her RE since Rally really hasn't done much for me. Rally was a fantastic intro to competition sports in general (we got started when Cohen was ~8 months old or so) but I find it's a bit lackluster as a sport. I like the precision and drive required in obedience, and the exhilaration in agility. I find Rally allows for sloppy performances and I don't want to get accustomed to that. I may go back with Cohen in a few more years once I really get her obedience down, but in the mean time it's on the back burner after RE.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
#26
Cohen can get really flat in the ring, so I've been reading a lot about play via Denise Fenzi and I'm planning on taking some private lessons with a new obedience instructor but I haven't made the appointments yet. I think I've fallen into a fairly common trap where I rely too heavily on food and other constant reinforcement so when the motivation isn't there the performance suffers.
Not saying this is YOU, just a general observation. Food or reward generally isn't a problem. It's a part, but mostly I see people get too serious and try and do too much routine. Do this heeling patter, do that, retrieve to front, doesn't get quite right, back up and make front, then good and food. Over and over.

Break it up small and short, get the pieces trained, then do them all with play. Nothing is the same and nothing is expected. Keeps the dog guessing and engaged. In the end when pieces are joined together and rewards are held longer the dogs become MORE engaged and push HARDER because they know what gets them the good stuff and it will eventually come, but you have to balance it in the beginning like anything else so you don't make them push too long and check out, but at the same time you have to keep them working and not dependant on food and cues.

Overall I see people asking for way too much too soon with too much pattern. I think that kills performance overall
 

Sekah

The Monster.
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
1,339
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Toronto
#27
Not saying this is YOU, just a general observation. Food or reward generally isn't a problem. It's a part, but mostly I see people get too serious and try and do too much routine. Do this heeling patter, do that, retrieve to front, doesn't get quite right, back up and make front, then good and food. Over and over.

Break it up small and short, get the pieces trained, then do them all with play. Nothing is the same and nothing is expected. Keeps the dog guessing and engaged. In the end when pieces are joined together and rewards are held longer the dogs become MORE engaged and push HARDER because they know what gets them the good stuff and it will eventually come, but you have to balance it in the beginning like anything else so you don't make them push too long and check out, but at the same time you have to keep them working and not dependant on food and cues.

Overall I see people asking for way too much too soon with too much pattern. I think that kills performance overall
You make some good points. I think for the most part over the last 6 months we've just been working on individual elements, and I've not bothered putting everything into a proper sequence since, well, the last time we were in a comp ring. It's tough to get a handle on how our brief practices are faring, considering the issue was keeping the motivation up throughout the entire exercises. As I said, I'm waiting to see an instructor before I even try putting it all together again. A fresh and experienced pair of eyes will be very helpful.

I really love teaching the individual exercises too, so Cohen has had an understanding of all the Open and Utility exercises for a good long time now. I think right now though I've focused too much on the mechanics of the exercises rather than the drive required while doing them.

But don't get me wrong - she's a good little obedience dog. I tend to be pretty hard on myself and like to keep people's expectations low. Makes life easier. :p
 

Flyinsbt

New Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2012
Messages
886
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland, OR
#28
It's a nice routine, but I wouldn't call it oozing with drive by any means. I've seen plenty of IPO dogs that aren't very drivey in OB too, but I wouldn't call that a drivey routine.
Trust me, the dog is oozing with drive. I've seen him in person. It's harder to see in the video, because you can't see that he's about to jump out of his skin, but his every move is fully engaged. He's a big dog with a long stride, and to keep him precise in that small ring the drive has to be capped, but it is very much there.

when he goes over the top, he barks
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_K1Ud92s9s

So she has to keep him really in check.
 
Last edited:

AdrianneIsabel

Glutton for Crazy
Joined
Aug 29, 2010
Messages
8,893
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland, Oregon
#29
He looks fantastic, my biggest gripe about AKC obedience is the inconsistency of hand allowances. I have been told by judges I cannot glue my hand my my stomach, as such. It makes me very uncomfortable not knowing exactly can I can and cannot do with any given judge.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
#30
He looks fantastic, my biggest gripe about AKC obedience is the inconsistency of hand allowances. I have been told by judges I cannot glue my hand my my stomach, as such. It makes me very uncomfortable not knowing exactly can I can and cannot do with any given judge.
Lots of hip tapping, finger targets and handler help. Didn't realize so much was allowed.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
#31
Trust me, the dog is oozing with drive. I've seen him in person. It's harder to see in the video, because you can't see that he's about to jump out of his skin, but his every move is fully engaged. He's a big dog with a long stride, and to keep him precise in that small ring the drive has to be capped, but it is very much there.

when he goes over the top, he barks
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_K1Ud92s9s

So she has to keep him really in check.
you can tell me it's there, but i see average
 

Flyinsbt

New Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2012
Messages
886
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland, OR
#32
He looks fantastic, my biggest gripe about AKC obedience is the inconsistency of hand allowances. I have been told by judges I cannot glue my hand my my stomach, as such. It makes me very uncomfortable not knowing exactly can I can and cannot do with any given judge.
You can hold your hand at your stomach when you heel, but tensing up and grabbing onto your shirt (which I tend to do) is not preferable. You're supposed to look "natural". So you just hold your hand casually at your waist. Like one so naturally does.

If any judge tells you differently, they're wrong.
 

Aleron

New Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2011
Messages
2,269
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
NE Ohio
#36
It's a nice routine, but I wouldn't call it oozing with drive by any means. I've seen plenty of IPO dogs that aren't very drivey in OB too, but I wouldn't call that a drivey routine.
I tend to agree. The dog seems happy but that's not the same as "oozing with drive".

I can see where people could get the impression that AKC obedience isn't done in drive. Certainly I see less dogs working in drive at trials than I see dogs working in drive. I think at the upper levels, you see more drivey performances but even at that, there's certainly some rather flat OTCH dogs. I think keeping the dog precise and very up can be an issue and "up-ness" isn't scoreable, so precision is favored.

Oh! I can start with a question... How does everyone teach "front?"
Jagger has the best fronts of any dog I have had and I taught him by teaching him to target a piece of duct tape, then sticking it to my shirt, then fading it fairly quickly. I did get quite a bit of bumping early on...ok more like slamming into me when he couldn't stop but he settled into a nice front with some work. Unless he's too excited. I learned to stand very firmly on the recall ;)
 

Flyinsbt

New Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2012
Messages
886
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland, OR
#37
Well, that's a training video, as opposed to competition, so it's not a direct comparison. However, I don't see those dogs exhibiting more drive, except in vocalizing and fidgety performance, which a person would want to avoid in obedience competition. And you can train past them, without squelching the dogs drive, you just have to channel it very specifically, as Petra did with Tyler.
(when I say "you", I mostly mean people other than myself. I'm not so good at it myself.)
 

Flyinsbt

New Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2012
Messages
886
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland, OR
#38
I tend to agree. The dog seems happy but that's not the same as "oozing with drive".

I can see where people could get the impression that AKC obedience isn't done in drive. Certainly I see less dogs working in drive at trials than I see dogs working in drive. I think at the upper levels, you see more drivey performances but even at that, there's certainly some rather flat OTCH dogs. I think keeping the dog precise and very up can be an issue and "up-ness" isn't scoreable, so precision is favored.
Again, I didn't say the performance itself was oozing with drive, I said the dog was, and he is. I do see intense drive in that performance, though. Drive isn't just about being fast and twitchy, drive is about being intensely engaged in the task at hand, and he is. Getting a dog with higher drive like that to remain so intensely engaged while also staying precise is difficult, I know, because I haven't been able to do it. So my drivier dog is a terrible obedience dog, she doesn't really engage with it because it's not fast paced enough to keep her. If I was a better trainer, she could be good like that. Instead, she's a fabulous agility dog, with a CD.

You just don't keep a dog engaged with a heeling pattern this long unless the dog is working in drive.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnBjxHXwLrM
 

AdrianneIsabel

Glutton for Crazy
Joined
Aug 29, 2010
Messages
8,893
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland, Oregon
#39
I'm not sure how a video of training can be used to compare to drive in an AKC ring.

The ability to remain "up" and flashy in the AKC ring says a lot to me about a dog, we've see a lot of struggles with several owners, several breeds, and several training methods. It is a challenge and when you see it come together its is something to be admired, IMO.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top