Bias and hypocricy of views

Xandra

Active Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2009
Messages
3,806
Likes
0
Points
36
question..do you use fly wipe to keep the flies from eating off the tips of their ears? I am assuming you have flies where you live. I don't think anyone is really exempt from them. THat is a preventative. ANd you say you feed them. Why do you not expect them to kill their own food if you insist that they live a wild life? DO you clip nails? IF you do not remove the dewclaw that is necessary no matter what they run on. I am just curious? What about eye injury? IS the dog expected to go on with one eye since there is no vet care...even tho it could be treated easily? WHat if they need stitches? Do you do that yourself? WHat difference is it between your doing it or a vet?
From his other thread, in response to what he considers emergency (ie, when he goes to the vet):
A broken bone, an eye injury, a rattle snake bite, eating poison, etc. Some chronic diseases caused by a manufactured food, exposure to household chemicals may be needed to be identified...Dogs are not immortal anyway, but a genetically healthy, good working and intelligent dogs deserve good care.
His dog seemed to have nice, full ears...
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
THat's good. I missed that post i guess. I Thought he said he didn't vet. I couldn't for the life imagine someone not doing so or why.
 

DanL

Active Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
3,933
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
61
First, ANY dog can bite. Second if an owner dosn't know dogs well enough to read that kind of behavior they don't need a dog. And what has a person done to the dog to cause him to react that way?
Of course any dog can bite. But a stable dog with an even temperament and proper training is a lot less likely to bite than a nerve bag dog that doesn't have any training. And I agree- someone who can't read their dog's behavior shouldn't have one, but we both know that is rarely a criteria for dog ownership. Breeders who take pride in their dogs and who screen their potential puppy owners wouldn't sell a dog to someone like that, but a bad breeder with poorly bred dogs who doesn't care who gets a pup isn't going to look twice at who is buying the dog, only that their money is green.

I'm speaking strictly from a bad genetics point of view, not from an environmental one. The original point I argued was the statement about "a dog can't help the way it was born", and in my hypothetical case, the dog was born as a fearful dog where a person doesn't have to do anything to have him react. The kind of dog that's scared of his own shadow but from a dog breed that might have been a working breed at some point so it's penchant for using it's teeth is engrained in it's history.
 
Joined
Jun 21, 2008
Messages
2,617
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
37
Location
Glendale Arizona
THat's good. I missed that post i guess. I Thought he said he didn't vet. I couldn't for the life imagine someone not doing so or why.
I have had Bailey for 5 years and she has seen the vet twice. This may make me a bad person, but the only time she's been was when she was spayed, and then again when she had an allergic reaction.

But she is as useful as a throw pillow anyway (dont tell her I said that,) So shes pretty low maintenence.
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
Believe me i am the last one to run to the vet for minor things. Still we have shots and heartworm tests when it is necessary. VIctor must see a vet for an all clear for his therapy dog job once a year. I have had PEpper two years and she has been three times. First for her heartworm test and vaccinations. THe second for the growth that formed between her toes that was making her limp. THe third because i thought the growth was coming back since she was limping again on the same foot...but it was a joint injury that healed up on it's own. Mary went over a decade with no problems but as she aged things happen like the mole on her eyelid that was scratching the surface of her eye. I apologize to the OP. I thought I read no vet and that just made my heart sink to think animals were being treated that way.

. I had a cat that went almost 17 years without a problem. HE made up for it with his first two years of life however. He had infection after infection but we got his immune system built up and after that for an indoor outdoor cat He was incredibly lucky.
 

MafiaPrincess

Obvious trollsare Obvious
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
6,135
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
41
Location
Ontario
Except back on post 17 of that other thread.. he doesn't vet for even snake bites.. So the contradictions are endless. Seems not to vet for anything at all, as it's better for his gene pool. If a snake bite and a breech pup aren't emergencies I can't fathom what actually might count as one.

Only emergency can send me to a vet. My dogs recover snake bites, no fatalities so far. Copperheads are no problem. They still avoided rattlers. In their home country, if the dog got sick, it either dies, or survives. No vets. Natural selection takes care about weak and unfit. This is why they live a long and healthy life.
 

-bogart-

Member of WHODAT Nation.
Joined
Jun 9, 2008
Messages
3,192
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
South East Louisiana
yeah see how they recover from them also mafia, and they avoid the others .

please point out where he said he would not take a breech pup , for the life of me i can not find the post. got a post number or something, i remember vaguly him saying something about breech but cannot find out what
 

Xandra

Active Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2009
Messages
3,806
Likes
0
Points
36
He didn't contradict himself... he said they recovered from snake bites so far, said the bites were from copperheads and said that they hadn't been bitten by a rattlesnake... then said that he would take them to a vet for a rattlesnake bite.

Do a google on the use of copperhead antivenin in dogs... didn't seem to be highly recommended. In large dogs, the bites aren't often fatal and it isn't uncommon for dogs to have an allergic reaction to the antivenin and die.

So a vet is going to look at the dog, maybe try and convince the owner to buy some antivenin, keep the dog (which is stressful for it), give it IV fluids and painkillers, and they wait... if the dog lives you get it back along with a huge bill, if it dies you get a phone call and a huge-er bill. So I guess the opinion of the OP is that if some IV is what is going to save the dog, it can't be very hardy.

Rattlesnake bites are more severe and antivenin seems to be the usual course of action... and so they go to the vet.
 

Romy

Taxiderpy
Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Messages
10,233
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Olympia, WA
He didn't contradict himself... he said they recovered from snake bites so far, said the bites were from copperheads and said that they hadn't been bitten by a rattlesnake... then said that he would take them to a vet for a rattlesnake bite.

Do a google on the use of copperhead antivenin in dogs... didn't seem to be highly recommended. In large dogs, the bites aren't often fatal and it isn't uncommon for dogs to have an allergic reaction to the antivenin and die.

So a vet is going to look at the dog, maybe try and convince the owner to buy some antivenin, keep the dog (which is stressful for it), give it IV fluids and painkillers, and they wait... if the dog lives you get it back along with a huge bill, if it dies you get a phone call and a huge-er bill. So I guess the opinion of the OP is that if some IV is what is going to save the dog, it can't be very hardy.

Rattlesnake bites are more severe and antivenin seems to be the usual course of action... and so they go to the vet.
Most folks that hunt with hounds, that I know of personally, learn how to start an IV themselves as it can save your dog's life if it gets injured out in the field. I don't know if the OP is one of these though.

I also know folks who have had their vets show them how to put in stitches, since the faster it can get stitched together the less scarring, and faster the recovery time is. Also, if you do it immediately after the injury, they are still full of adrenalin and don't complain about being sewn together. For sighthounds whose skin tears easily this is an advantage since they are also sensitive to many of the anesthetics and painkillers used.
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
ufimych
Puppy Dog Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Virginia, USA
Posts: 87

My Adel gave birth to 10 puppies

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yes, she is 3 years old now and I breed her for the first time. As I wrote earlier, my Saluki live outside a year around here, in Virginia climate. No problem with this, only benefits. They are ready to jump out of their pens and run at any moment, when I am ready. Adel gave birth to pups on July 3 and I know who will buy my puppies. Even while nursing the pups, she does not mind to run for five-ten minutes and even flash a rabbit! She eats 2-3 pounds of ground beef per day and the pups grow rapidly.

Prior to giving birth, she cleaned inside the doghouse, leaving just bare plywood floor. Everything is going on naturally. No vets involved and I do not intervene, except handling the pups.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
HE doesn't say however what he would do if things went wrong.
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
2,242
Likes
0
Points
0
ufimych
Puppy Dog Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Virginia, USA
Posts: 87

My Adel gave birth to 10 puppies

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yes, she is 3 years old now and I breed her for the first time. As I wrote earlier, my Saluki live outside a year around here, in Virginia climate. No problem with this, only benefits. They are ready to jump out of their pens and run at any moment, when I am ready. Adel gave birth to pups on July 3 and I know who will buy my puppies. Even while nursing the pups, she does not mind to run for five-ten minutes and even flash a rabbit! She eats 2-3 pounds of ground beef per day and the pups grow rapidly.

Prior to giving birth, she cleaned inside the doghouse, leaving just bare plywood floor. Everything is going on naturally. No vets involved and I do not intervene, except handling the pups.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
HE doesn't say however what he would do if things went wrong.

I believe hes refering to the birthing process..

at least thats how I read it.
 

Romy

Taxiderpy
Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Messages
10,233
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Olympia, WA
Lucky for us and our dogs, most snake bites do not involve much venom. In cases where there is a lot of envemonation, the dog is not likely to survive even with veterinary help.

I know of a borzoi who was bitten on the nose, and his owner managed to save using the vet and a lot of antivenom. In the end, he survived the bite but it drove him insane. He had to be put down a year later because the brain damage was so severe, he was dangerous to be around.

ETA: This was a rattlesnake bite.
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
2,242
Likes
0
Points
0
Lots of vipers give dry bites...in fact they prefer too...venom is precious and why waste it when the teeth alone will do?


In fact I've even seen my vipers give dry bites to PREY!


They are stingy with the stuff
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top