ok, heres my point of view, from someone who was a minor and by most rescues is still considered a minor. I am 19, and moved out on my own, etc. I tried to adopt a dog from the humane society and they wouldnt even talk to me because I wasnt 21, and the other organization wouldnt talk to me because I am not a "family". Personally I think this is rediculous, and I think breeders doing it is rediculous also. I think that yes they should be asking the minor all the same questions as the adults and yes there should be a little more to make sure that the minor will be responsible, but I dont think they should not talk to someone just because they are a minor, or rule them out because of it.
and as for the whole minor not being home all the time, well you have great breeders selling puppies to owners where they work 8 hour days. It just seems like some on here are saying that because they arent minors they will be home for the dog, etc. Adults go out with friends and work 8 hours days, etc. so they technically wont be home for the dog all the time either. What about people who live by themselves and work 8 hour days and such, would you not sell a puppy to them because no one else will be home to care for their dog?
While yes I think breeders need to be selective of who buys their puppies, I think certain things could be a little less strict. Beemer, my dog, didnt come from a perfect breeder, she didnt have a contract, but she did show her dogs, but didnt have titles on all that she bred. But she was the only breeder I could find that was clsoe to what I was looking for, in the price and driving range that I could go for that would actually sell a dog to me. The fact that I live with roommate and am under 21 yrs of age played big against me when looking at rescues AND breeders. And I think thats why some people do go to "less then reputable breeders" to get pets, because sometimes its just really hard to get one from a reputable breeder.
ok sorry for the long post lol