Mini Aussie/American Shepherd was not my first choice of breed, but my parents wouldn't allow any dogs that grow over 25~30 lbs. My first choice of breed was either Dobes or GSDs-- I liked both the media portrayal, their appearances, AND temperaments... (this was about 5~6 years ago) based on my limited research. But my parents wouldn't allow those size dogs AT ALL. So... options limited. :hail:
I didn't want anything too tiny, frail, or any smallwhitefluffies, and I wasn't into terriers/beards. I mainly looked for appearance and intelligence (now I know more, hopefully LOL). I was originally really into Papillons and their intelligence ratings online and all that (basically, trick learning skills), but I decided that they were too small/delicate for what I wanted. My first real choice was Brittanies. But there were no good breeders nearby, and when I showed my mom their pictures, she didn't love what they looked like enough (figures). Mini Aussie was my second choice, and my mom thought they were adorable... Sooo looked here and there, BYB galore but I had no idea, and Rara appeared.
We loved Rara through and through, from temperament to appearance to size... so my mom, one day, BROUGHT IT UP HERSELF, said she'd want another Mini Aussie. I said mhm, yes, agreed, Rara needs a friend obviously, yes of course. (more dogs? UM, YES PLEASE WANT.) By then, I'd already done all my research and become at least decently knowledgeable about the dog world and breeding. But I really wanted a Collie (still do). We were THIS CLOSE to picking up a sweet 35 lb Rough Collie from Southland Collie Rescue... when my mom suddenly came to the conclusion that the collie probably had dental issues that the rescue wasn't disclosing to us, AND she thought the collie was "too big", so the plan was dropped on literally the day before we were going to go visit her/pick her up. I was pretty upset.
Back to Mini Aussies, my mom found a random breeding between a farm working Aussie and an Aussie family pet way out in the country in the middle of nowhere. I still secretly really wanted a big dog. So when she showed me the pictures, I casually chose the biggest puppy in the litter... little does she know. LMAO. So Lancer appeared. And yeah, he's like 45 lbs now and his parents were both ~27 lbs, so my evil plan worked and nobody calls him a MAS anymore.
Still GSD for my next dog though. I COMPLETELY ADORE my dogs, but I'd love to work with different breeds of my own choice through research.
TL;DR Got Mini Aussies because my parents wanted small, smart dogs, I still would like a GSD or two in the future, got huge Lancer through secret evil plan.